Analysis · Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker

Captain Toad can't jump, and that limit is what makes the puzzles work

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A hero who can't jump, in a world you turn by hand

Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker is built on one rule: its hero can't jump. Captain Toad and Toadette carry backpacks too heavy for it, so each level is a small diorama that you rotate until a hidden path shows itself. Critics judged the whole game by that idea. Game Informer's Ben Reeves was surprised by how much depth and variety the levels found without a single jump. GamesRadar+'s Matthew Castle saw the same rule as a gimmick the game never fully justified, and pointed to ladders standing in where a jump would do.

That split is a useful way to read everything else. When the rule creates a puzzle, the game shines. When it only takes something away, it gets in the way.

Where the no-jump rule pays off

Every level ends at a star. Getting there means pulling plants out of the ground to throw, dodging enemies with only two hitpoints, and turning the stage to see around corners. On Wii U, the GamePad gives you more ways to handle the diorama: touch the screen to slide platforms, blow into the microphone to move others, tilt to aim. Reeves praised how those inputs made each level distinct, and GameSpot's Peter Brown called it a rare Wii U game best played on the GamePad itself. Polygon said it lacked the depth of a mainline Mario game but called the execution "pure Nintendo", with ideas that kept changing.

Brown also liked the boss fights and how their difficulty grew, along with the hard-to-reach collectibles and the replay conditions, such as clearing a level without taking damage. Those extra goals are where a jumpless hero earns the most, because a second pass through a familiar box asks you to look at it differently.

The charm helps too. Critics singled out the small visual details, and Electronic Gaming Monthly's Andrew Fitch and IGN's Marty Sliva both found Captain Toad a fresh change from Mario's personality. Polygon thought the plot was thin but said the play made up for it.

A game about turning the world needs a better camera

Since everything depends on rotating the view, the camera is where critics found the most trouble. Eurogamer's Oli Welsh said it was often zoomed too far in or out. Fitch had to spin it while enemies closed in. Reeves wanted an automatic option and worried that newer or older players would struggle without one. Sliva added that the motion controls were always on, so the view moved when nobody meant it to.

The other complaint is size. Fitch's main gripe was that there was "just not enough of it" and that the difficulty barely climbed. Reeves agreed the game is small but argued that every level is dense, with no filler. Castle and Fitch also felt it never settled on being a puzzle game or a platformer. Welsh thought the hybrid worked, though he felt Mario vs. Donkey Kong did it better.

The Switch and 3DS versions trade levels and add a weak co-op mode

The 2018 Switch and 3DS releases keep the core and change the edges. The levels based on Super Mario 3D World are gone. In their place are four bonus levels based on Super Mario Odyssey, opened with Amiibo or by finishing the game. Reeves called the swap a "fair exchange", while Polygon thought most of the new levels fell short of the original puzzles. Both Reeves and 4Players' Jan Wobbeking found it tedious to replay missions to earn them. The pixel Toad hide-and-seek challenges no longer need a Toad Amiibo, and 18 more levels followed as paid DLC.

Co-op is the weakest addition. In one mode, player two gets a pointer that tosses turnips. In the other, player two controls a second Toad. GameSpot's Daniel Starkey said splitting the roles left both players with too little to do. IGN's Joe Skrebels noted that the pointer can defeat enemies anywhere, which removes their threat. These puzzles are built for one person turning the box, and a second player mostly gets in the way.

  • Switch: when docked, a motion cursor appears. Reeves found it obnoxious because it stays on screen; Nintendo Life's Glen Fox didn't mind it and preferred docked play for the better graphics.
  • 3DS: the graphics are scaled down, but Skrebels called it one of the best-looking games on the console and said the 3D effect improved the play. Nintendo Life's Chris Scullion liked the GamePad features moved to the second screen but found the graphics jagged when zoomed out.
  • Wii U: the original, with the 3D World levels and the GamePad's full set of touch, microphone and motion controls.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet