Analysis · Uncharted: The Lost Legacy

Chloe Frazer takes the lead in an Uncharted critics ranked among 2017's best

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Tenth on one list, 47th on another

The highest praise came from GamesRadar+, which ranked The Lost Legacy tenth on its list of the 25 best games of 2017. Game Informer went further on one point and gave it Best Graphics in its 2017 Action Game of the Year Awards. IGN nominated it in four categories, including Best Story and Best PlayStation 4 Game.

The sharpest criticism is mild by comparison. Polygon still listed it among the 50 best games of the year, but only at 47th, and the smaller of the two aggregates puts it at 81/100 across 31 reviews. Next to the 85/100 and 91% scores drawn from 142 reviews, that's a split between "very good" and "one of the year's best", not between good and bad.

The aggregator summed up the reception as "generally favorable". Eurogamer placed it 18th in its top 50 for 2017 and EGMNow ranked it 21st. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 8.3 out of 10.

A new lead, and the series holds up without Drake

This is the first Uncharted game without Nathan Drake. You play Chloe Frazer, a treasure hunter searching for the Tusk of Ganesh in India's Western Ghats mountains. Ex-mercenary Nadine Ross works with her, and together they try to stop a warlord and his insurgent army from starting a civil war.

Removing a series' star is a big risk, and critics' response suggests it worked. IGN's Best Story nomination is the clearest sign that the writing held up without Drake. The game also leaves room for its two leads between fights, with long stretches of conversation and a dialogue tree that lets you choose how some of those talks end.

It began as a standalone expansion to Uncharted 4: A Thief's End, and it was still treated as a full game. Lists of the year's best ranked it alongside the year's biggest releases, not as an add-on.

Larger maps, same linear spine

The most concrete change from Uncharted 4 is scale. The maps are larger, and the environments offer several routes through towns, buildings and temples. Some segments add driving, and puzzles mixed with platforming break up the climbing and gunfights.

It is still a linear game, though. The wider spaces give you more room to explore, but they don't turn it into an open world. If you're expecting to wander freely, expect a wider corridor rather than open country.

  • Chloe can jump, sprint, climb, swim and swing, which carries most of the movement.
  • Travel switches between going on foot and driving a vehicle.
  • Story progress depends on solving puzzles as much as on winning fights.

Fights you can skip, and a partner who helps

The combat options are rifles, shotguns, pistols, revolvers, grenades and C4, plus melee. Stealth is the real addition. Silenced weapons are new for the series, so you can take enemies out quietly or slip past them without a fight.

Enemies react to what you do, coordinate tactics and work as a group. Your companion is run by the game too and pulls her weight. She throws objects to stun threats, calls out enemies you can't see and joins in with her own weapons. That support is part of why the Chloe and Nadine partnership sits at the center of the game instead of being just a story device.

The game rewards patience: quiet tools, a partner who spots for you, and room to choose your route.

One thing to know going in is that online play isn't new. The Lost Legacy gives you access to Uncharted 4's multiplayer with some added content tied to this game, so the single-player campaign is what you're really getting.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet