Analysis · Civilization III

Civilization III kept the Civ II formula and added small wonders on top

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The first Civilization without Sid Meier as designer

Civilization III, released on October 30, 2001, is the third main game in the series and the one that came before Civilization IV. It still carries Sid Meier's name on the box, but he didn't design it. Jeff Briggs, a game designer, and Soren Johnson, a game programmer, led the design.

That handoff matters, because the team inherited a hard brief. Reviewing the PC version for Next Generation, Jeff Lundrigan gave it five stars out of five. He argued that Civ II had come so close to perfect that a sequel could really only add to it, not change it. That's a fair way to read Civilization III: it's an expansion of a proven design, not a reinvention.

Almost everything from Civ II is still here

The core loop will be familiar to anyone who knows the earlier games. The map is a grid of square tiles. Each terrain type yields food, production (shown as shields) and trade when a city works it. A city can work only the twenty tiles around it, and only as many tiles as it has population. Cities have to sit at least one tile apart.

  • Food grows cities, and any surplus is stored.
  • Shields build units, buildings and wonders.
  • Commerce is split however you choose between research, tax revenue and luxuries.

Worker units build the terrain improvements. Irrigation adds food, mines add production, and roads add commerce and speed up movement. Citizens are happy, content, unhappy or resisting. If most of a city turns unhappy, it falls into civil disorder and production stops. If the disorder lasts, riots can destroy improvements. The great Wonders of the World return too, and each one can be built only once per game.

Small wonders were the headline addition

The clearest new system is the Small Wonder. A Small Wonder works like a regular wonder, except that every civilization can build its own copy, not just the first one to finish it. Wall Street, the Forbidden Palace and The Pentagon are examples. Most need a social condition as well as a technology, so they reward how you run your empire and not only how fast you research.

There's a catch that makes them more than a free bonus. When an enemy captures a city that holds a Small Wonder, the wonder is destroyed. Where you build one becomes a defensive decision.

The rest of the structure pushes the same way. Buildings cost money every turn to maintain, and each city can have only one of each type. The tech tree is split into four ages: Ancient, Middle, Industrial and Modern. Moving up an age requires specific technologies, while optional branches give useful bonuses and new forms of government. Diplomacy affects movement too. You can only use another civilization's roads after the two of you sign a Right of passage treaty.

Critics loved it, the launch build less so

Critics praised it widely when it came out. It won the PC Strategy award at the AIAS' 5th Annual Interactive Achievement Awards and was nominated for Computer Game of the Year and Game of the Year. Computer Games Magazine named it both the best strategy title and the best overall computer game of 2001. PC Gamer US gave it its 2001 Best Turn-Based Strategy Game prize, saying it recaptured what was great about the earlier games while adding "a few great new strokes." Computer Gaming World nominated it for Best Strategy Game, though that award went to Kohan: Immortal Sovereigns.

Buyers responded too. It entered NPD Intelect's weekly US computer game chart at the top spot for October 28 to November 3, 2001.

The weak spot was the release itself: the first version shipped with bugs and glitches.

A patch arrived soon after launch, and later patches improved how the game played. They also added features such as the group movement command, which some players felt should have been there from the start. The game's reputation rests on the patched version, not the one that first hit shelves.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet