Civilization IV rewards the patient empire builder and stumbles mainly online
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for players who think in centuries
Civilization IV is built for the strategy player who likes slow, compounding decisions. You start with a small group of people and few resources, and every choice about where to settle, what to research and when to fight shapes an empire that has to last thousands of years. It's a 4X game in the classic mold: explore, expand, exploit and exterminate, one turn at a time.
For that player it delivers almost everywhere. Critics gave it a Metacritic aggregate of 94, and its critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.8 out of 10. In 2016, Time put it 11th on its list of the 50 best video games of all time, and in 2021 PCGamesN ranked it the best game in the series.
If you want quick sessions or fast action, it doesn't fit. The game's age ratings (Everyone 10+ and PEGI 12) say it's fine for younger players, but the pace still asks for patience.
Five ways to win keep the long game open
The game doesn't push every player toward war. You can win in any of these ways:
- Defeat every other civilization militarily.
- Control more than two-thirds of the world's land and population.
- Build the first spaceship and send it to Alpha Centauri.
- Lead every rival on culture.
- Be voted World Leader through the United Nations.
If the game timer runs out first, the civilization with the highest running score wins. That range matters: a builder who hates combat and a warmonger can sit at the same map and both have a real path to victory.
The setup adds variety too. There are 34 civilizations, each with its own leader, starting technology, strengths, weaknesses and unique units. Terrain such as plains, tundra and desert decides what resources you can pull from the land and how units move across it, and fog of war hides whatever you haven't explored. You can also tune the map and the AI difficulty before each game.
Smarter rivals were the headline improvement
The most consistent praise went to the computer opponents. IGN wrote that the AI was much more intelligent than in Civilization III, and GameSpot's Andrew Park singled out how difficult the AI opponents were. Designer Soren Johnson credited a "secret pre-beta group" that tested the game before release. Computer Games Magazine gave it awards for Best AI and Best Interface on top of naming it the best computer game of 2005.
This is where it pays off for its audience. A strategy game is only as good as the opposition, and critics agreed this one fights back. PC Gamer US's Dan Stapleton called it "a huge facelift" to a formula that already worked.
The visuals drew praise as well. The Times liked the improved 3D engine and GameGuru liked being able to zoom down to individual squares. Keep in mind that this was praise in 2005, so it tells you the game looked good for its time, not how it compares today.
Where it falls short
The complaints cluster around multiplayer and a few interface details. Multiplayer itself was a step forward: Game Revolution said it "actually works this time", and the game supports single-player, hot seat and online play. The menus around it are another story. GameSpy's Dave Kosak called the multiplayer interface "a little rough in places" and noted that the built-in server browser kept jumping around while you tried to pick a game. IGN's Steve Butts wanted an option to save login details.
Butts also argued that news of enemy achievements should show up more prominently, which matters in a game where a rival's quiet progress toward a space or culture win can catch you late.
The other gap is design. GameSpot pointed out that there's no religion-based victory condition, which made the revamped religion system feel less important than it was meant to be.
None of these flaws touch the core loop critics loved. They're friction around the edges, felt most by online players.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Civilization IV en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2377 wikidata.org