Civilization V got hexes and city defense right and its rivals wrong
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Called the series' peak and faulted for its opponents
Kotaku called Civilization V "the pinnacle of the Civilization experience" 10 years after its release. 1UP.com said it had an "A.I. that can't play the game." Both views hold up, and the game makes the most sense once you accept that both are true.
The praise is broad. It holds a Metacritic score of 90/100 from 70 reviews, and its critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.8. G4TV gave it 5 out of 5 and called it the most accessible entry for new and old players alike. IGN scored it 9.0 and said it was the first PC Civilization worth almost anyone's time. GameSpot singled out how addictive it is, warning it would keep players up "long past your bedtime".
Hexes and one unit per tile changed how war works
Rock, Paper, Shotgun named it one of its top 50 PC games of the decade. The outlet credited it with moving the series from squares to hexes and allowing only one fighting unit per map tile. That one rule ends the old habit of piling a whole army onto a single square. Armies now spread out, and where each unit stands matters.
Sieges changed too. In earlier games a city was only as strong as the units parked inside it. Here, cities defend themselves:
- A city has its own hit points and falls when they reach zero.
- It can fire a ranged attack at enemies up to two tiles away.
- A city that survives an attack recovers about 15% of its hit points each turn.
- Melee units lose hit points whenever they attack a city, and a garrison or defensive buildings make the city tougher.
Taking a city therefore means bringing ranged support and pressing the attack over several turns, not throwing one stack at a wall. Rock, Paper, Shotgun argued this edition "arguably set the high water mark" for the series, even after Civilization VI arrived.
The AI is the flaw nearly every critic named
On paper, the computer opponents are ambitious. The AI runs on four levels, from individual units up through the war front, the whole empire and long-term plans for winning. Each rival leader gets a personality built from 26 "flavors", such as expansion, military and naval preferences, so no two games play out quite alike.
Critics mostly agreed it didn't work. Eurogamer gave the game 8/10 but called the AI "curiously terrible". GameShark gave it a B+ and said computer opponents were "ill equipped" for warfare. G4TV called the AI "fairly average" and the diplomacy "anemic". IGN's complaint ran the other way, calling the AI too aggressive.
Lead designer Jon Shafer later accepted the criticism. He said the opponents were so tied to their immediate situation that they
"appeared random"
and drifted from one strategy to the next without a clear plan. For a game built around outthinking rival nations, that's a real cost, and it hurts most in solo play.
What a match asks of you, and who should play
Each player leads a civilization from a single settlement across thousands of years. You found cities with settler units, grow them, pick what they build and steer research, culture, food and the economy. City borders grow on their own toward what the city needs, though you can buy tiles with gold. There are five ways to win:
- Conquer the world by force.
- Win a diplomatic vote as world leader.
- Gain influence over every civilization through tourism.
- Build a colony ship and win the space race.
- Hold the highest score when the turn limit runs out.
IGN warned that Civilization IV veterans may miss that game's civics and religion systems, so returning players should expect a leaner ruleset. Newcomers are who critics thought it suited best.
The co-op and multiplayer modes are the clearest way around the AI problem: human rivals don't drift between plans. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it's rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 12.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Civilization V en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2385 wikidata.org