Analysis · Paper Mario: Color Splash

Color Splash has sharp jokes, lovely paper and card fights critics dodged

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The fights are where critics split

The biggest disagreement about Color Splash is its combat. Battles are turn-based, and every attack is a card. You find cards in stages, win them from enemies or buy them with coins, then paint them to make them stronger and sort them on the Wii U GamePad's touchscreen.

Some critics liked it. Game Informer's Ben Reeves called the system simple but strategic, and thought it fixed the cramped feel of the stickers in Sticker Star. GamesRadar+'s Alex Jones saw some risk and reward in it, plus a little tactical puzzle-solving.

The critics who didn't like it said so more strongly. Jones also found the fights repetitive and said that picking and sorting cards for every encounter got tiresome, to the point of avoiding enemies. Nintendo Life's Conor McMahon and VentureBeat's Dennis Scimecaen found battles too easy to stay interesting. Polygon's Caty McCarthy saw little reason to keep fighting after the first five hours. Giant Bomb's Dan Ryckert gave the game 2/5 and called combat unnecessary, because of the way its economy loops back on itself:

Cards cost coins, and fights mostly pay you back in coins. If battles only refund what they spend, there's little reason to start one.

Almost everyone liked the writing and the paper

Away from the fights, critics agreed far more. Reeves praised its "belly-laugh moments", and McMahon thought the writing was a big step up from Sticker Star. Jones counted the script among the game's saving graces. IGN's Terry Schwartz called Mario's new ally Huey "endearing" but found the story itself generic, closer to a standard Super Mario plot than a story you'd remember.

The cast split opinion a little. GameSpot's Miguel Concepcion enjoyed how varied and funny the Toads were. Ryckert disliked that nearly every character was a Toad and felt they blurred together.

The look won over almost everyone. Concepcion said the move to HD made the paper style more appealing than ever and liked how everyday paper, such as toilet paper and wrapping paper, became part of the world and its puzzles. Jones called the visuals "the purest distillation" of the series' style and compared them with Yoshi's Woolly World and Kirby and the Rainbow Curse.

The paint hammer works, the cutouts don't

Mario carries a paint hammer that fills in colorless spots around the world using red, blue and yellow paint. Collecting hammer scraps raises how much paint he can carry. Ryckert wanted to paint every spot in every world. Concepcion found the early levels slow because the paint supply starts so small, but said the problem went away as capacity grew.

The cutout ability got a much colder reception. You trace a dotted line on the touchscreen to peel back part of the scenery and reveal hidden areas. Concepcion and Jones both called it unneeded, since it only turns up in out-of-the-way, tedious spots. Jason Hidalgo of the Reno Gazette-Journal thought the new features worked well, but warned they could be too hard for younger players. That matters for a game rated PEGI 3. Ryckert found the GamePad clumsy overall.

What the split says about who should play it

The scores show the same divide. On Metacritic it scored 76/100, which the site rates "generally favorable", yet only 58% of critics on OpenCritic recommended it. The critic average of 7.6 is calculated from those critic numbers. It's a good average with a lot of reservations behind it.

Those reservations mostly come from fans of the older games. Looking back, critics compared Color Splash unfavorably with Paper Mario (2000) and The Thousand-Year Door (2004) because it dropped so much of their RPG design. Reeves called it "almost unrecognizable as an RPG" but still fun. He and McCarthy said that without levels and stats, winning a fight felt hollow. Schwartz rated it far above Sticker Star but still short of the early games. USgamer called the combat "more of a chore" than a pleasure.

So the dividing line is clear:

  • Likely to enjoy it: players who come for the comedy, the papercraft world and light puzzles, and who see battles as a toll to pay between them.
  • Likely to be let down: anyone who wants character growth, satisfying fights or a story with real weight.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet