Analysis · Company of Heroes 3

Company of Heroes 3 nails the battles but stumbles on its Italian campaign map

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A direct sequel, nearly a decade after Company of Heroes 2

Company of Heroes 3 is Relic Entertainment's sequel to Company of Heroes 2, which came out in 2013. Sega publishes it, and it runs on Relic's Essence Engine. It reached Windows on February 23, 2023, and PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and Series S on May 30, 2023.

Relic has a long history with real-time strategy, from Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War to Age of Empires IV in 2021. This entry builds on that history instead of reinventing it. The war moves to new ground: you lead Allied forces through the invasion of Italy and Axis forces through the North African campaign.

The fair way to judge it is in two parts. The core battles are mostly the series as it was, with a few smart additions. The campaign structure around them is new, and it got most of the criticism.

What changed: a pause button and buildings that crumble brick by brick

The new features are aimed at the moment-to-moment fighting:

  • Tactical Pause. You can stop a battle, queue up orders and let them play out when the action resumes. Polygon said it makes for "a vastly more approachable game".
  • Finer destruction. Buildings now lose individual tiles and bricks rather than collapsing in big chunks. Eurogamer liked the spectacle, noting that "everything can be blown to bits".
  • Italian Partisans. These allied fighters, controlled by the game, can appear on the map or be called into battles.
  • A story that branches. How you deal with the game's commanders can change how the story ends.

The pause is the change most likely to matter to new players. Real-time strategy punishes anyone who can't click fast, and an RTS that lets you stop and think opens the genre to more people.

What it kept, and why that mostly worked

Critics who liked the game mostly liked it for its familiar parts. PCGamesN said the main story missions don't do much to move past Company of Heroes 2, but called them "a hell of a lot of fun". Kotaku argued that Italy is an even better fit for the series' tactical fights than earlier settings.

Rock Paper Shotgun went further, calling it the kind of "homecoming" fans would want from the series. The core of squads, cover and tanks in shattered towns held up, and the new destruction gives those fights more texture.

The Italian campaign map divided reviewers

The campaign map is the game's biggest swing, and it's where the strongest complaints landed. PC Gamer called the Italian campaign "fundamentally broken", pointing to enemy AI that rarely pushes and a subcommander system it described as confused. IGN enjoyed the set-piece battles but found the choices on the map so low-stakes that they felt like a waste of time. NPR found the campaign repetitive.

Not everyone was that harsh. Rock Paper Shotgun admitted some parts felt unpolished but was impressed by how much the Italian campaign offers for a first try at this style. Eurogamer had mixed feelings about how the North African campaign portrays Erwin Rommel.

The rule of thumb from the reviews: come for the battles, and treat the campaign map as a bonus.

Multiplayer and where the scores settled

NPR, the outlet most critical of the campaign's pace, praised the co-op and multiplayer, calling those matches fast and intense. That's a useful split: the slower campaign skirmishes and the online mode feel like different games. TouchArcade found it playable on a Steam Deck after a recent patch, though the visuals were inconsistent on the small screen and the controls take some getting used to.

Critic aggregates settled at 78/100, which gives a critic average of 7.8 (calculated from critic scores, not our own rating). On Metacritic, the PC and Xbox versions were rated "generally favorable" and the PlayStation 5 version "mixed or average". The game was also nominated for Best Sim / Strategy Game at The Game Awards 2023.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet