Analysis · Control

Control makes a shifting government building the star of a strong shooter

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The building is the main character

Control is built on a single idea: a government headquarters that is far larger inside than out. The Oldest House is a plain Brutalist tower in New York City. It holds the Federal Bureau of Control, a secret agency that studies things that break the laws of reality. Inside, the building shifts and ignores physics. GamesRadar's Sam Loveridge called it a "character of its own," and most of the praise for the game comes back to it.

You play Jesse Faden. She arrives looking for her missing brother and becomes the Bureau's new Director. An otherworldly force called the Hiss has possessed most of the staff. Critics agreed about the setting more than anything else. Game Informer's Ben Reeves called it "bizarrely fascinating." The Verge's Andrew Webster found it surreal and authentic at once, and GameSpot's Peter Brown said the art direction creates both dread and awe. In The Guardian, Steve Boxer wrote that it feels "believable and beyond bizarre."

Exploring the house pays off

The building's design suits the game's Metroidvania structure. The Oldest House has four sectors you can explore in any order. As Jesse's security clearance rises and she gains new skills, locked rooms and hidden areas open up. Several critics said this structure makes sense for the story: a building that rearranges itself should reveal itself slowly.

The house is packed with things to do between the 10 main acts:

  • 18 side quests
  • "Board Countermeasures" challenges that ask you to clear the Hiss under set conditions
  • Timed "Bureau Alerts"
  • Hidden documents, audio recordings, live-action video and TV shows that fill in the backstory

Control Points act as hubs. They heal Jesse and handle fast travel, upgrades, weapon mods and outfit changes. Boxer compared the game to Prey (2017) and said Jesse's powers make exploring more rewarding. Critics praised the in-game signs as surprisingly helpful for finding your way. The map was the weak spot: reviewers called it confusing to read, which is a real problem in a building this tangled.

Combat turns the building into ammunition

The fights also lean on the setting. Jesse's Launch power lets her hurl pieces of the environment at enemies, and Reeves called it the center of the combat. Her Service Weapon shapeshifts between forms, from a close-range shotgun blast to a long-range sniper shot, and you can equip two at a time. Separate cooldowns for the gun and the powers push you to switch between them. There's no cover system, and defeated enemies drop the health Jesse needs, so you have to stay on the move.

PC Gamer's James Davenport said Control has the best gunplay of any Remedy game, and compared its reward for aggressive play to Doom (2016). Polygon's Dave Tach called the combat "bombastic and satisfying" and pointed to how much of the world reacts to it. Three of the five base powers can only be found through exploration or side quests, so the building feeds the combat directly.

The complaints are about depth. Reeves found the other powers weak next to Launch. Several critics said upgrades don't change much later on and that there aren't enough enemy types to force new tactics. Webster called the gunplay generic and said the game leans too heavily on fighting, though he found the telekinetic powers thrilling.

The story is as strange as the house, for better and worse

Critics split on the story, and the split follows the setting. Brown liked Remedy's restrained storytelling and argued that its vagueness is what makes the game "spellbinding." Loveridge praised how it makes "even the ordinary feel extraordinary." Time's Matthew Gault stayed engaged from start to finish.

Others found the strangeness got in the way. Reeves said some characters' motives are too vague and parts of the plot confusing. Davenport called the story hard to get into at first and found Jesse "vapid." IGN's Jonathon Dornbush praised the "eclectic" supporting cast but called Jesse's own story an "afterthought." The house and the people in it hold the attention. The lead doesn't.

Several critics said the campaign ends abruptly. The side quests are what keep the game going afterward.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet