Analysis · Cossacks 3

Cossacks 3 rebuilds the 2000 original faithfully and adds very little to it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for players who still remember European Wars

Cossacks 3 was made for one kind of player above all: someone who played Cossacks: European Wars in 2000 and wants that game back. GSC Game World, the Ukrainian studio behind the original, describes it as a remake, and it stays close to its source. It's set in 17th and 18th century Europe again, and the 12 original nations return.

The setting, the nations and the scale of the battles all come from the 2000 game, so a returning player will recognize the shape of it right away. Critics asked whether recognition alone is enough.

For that player, the game delivers what it promises. For anyone hoping the series would move forward, critics were clear that it doesn't.

What it gives the returning player

The scale of the original is intact. The game lists these numbers:

  • 12 nations, the same lineup as the 2000 game
  • 70 types of unit
  • 100 technologies
  • more than 140 historical buildings
  • armies that number in the thousands

Battles mix ranged and close-quarters fighting, and terrain bonuses reward picking where to fight. The game's description also promises a realistic ballistics model. Random maps with flexible settings are back, which matters for a strategy game people replay for years rather than finish once.

Multiplayer supports up to 8 players, one more than the original. There's also co-op, plus single-player against the AI. It runs on Windows and Linux and is rated PEGI 12.

Where critics said it falls short

The main complaint is the game's whole premise. German magazine GameStar scored it 68 out of 100. It said the game leans on nostalgia, and that copying the original doesn't push the game forward. That's a fair charge against a remake that brings back the same nations, the same era and the same kind of huge battles.

The aggregate scores tell a similar story. Metacritic averaged critics at 63 out of 100, which it labels "mixed or average." Other aggregate figures range from 56% across 10 reviews to 68/100 across 9 reviews, with a 61/100 across 17 in between. No figure is a disaster, and none is a strong recommendation. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 6.5 out of 10.

A remake that matches its source closely has nothing to stand on beyond that source. Critics judged that Cossacks 3 doesn't go past it.

Who should look elsewhere

If you never played European Wars, Cossacks 3 has less to offer you. The draw is recognition, and critics didn't find enough new ideas to win over people without that memory. Players who want a historical strategy game that rethinks the genre won't find it here.

It holds up best as a large-scale multiplayer game. Eight-player matches, co-op and customizable random maps give a group of old fans plenty to play. Played alone, it depends on how much you enjoy managing massive armies against the AI, and that's the same appeal the original had.

Newcomers curious about the series can start with Cossacks: European Wars and Cossacks II: Napoleonic Wars, which show where this remake came from.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet