Analysis · Crackdown 2

Crackdown 2 doubles down on orb hunting and four-player co-op, and little else

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who chase orbs across rooftops

Crackdown 2 is for one kind of player: someone who sees a glowing orb on a tower roof and has to reach it. You play a super-powered officer called the Agent, working for a city-funded group known as the Agency. You get stronger by doing things. Shooting builds Firearms, punching and throwing objects builds Strength, grenades and launchers build Explosives, and stunts and races build Driving.

Agility is the skill that defines the game. It grows mostly by collecting Agility Orbs and Renegade Agility Orbs, and higher levels let the Agent jump higher, glide, and reach the helicopter landing pad on top of the Agency Tower. If that loop of climbing, collecting and leveling up sounds like a good evening, you're who the game was made for.

The game came out on July 6, 2010, as an Xbox 360 exclusive rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18. Its critic average, worked out from critic aggregates, is 6.7 out of 10, based on 16 reviews averaging 67/100.

Where it delivers: the climb and the co-op

Critics who liked Crackdown 2 kept coming back to the same two things. GameSpot, IGN and GameTrailers all praised the orb collecting, and GameTrailers called it addictive. The Escapist gave it four stars out of five for "satisfying, brainless fun" and said both newcomers and longtime fans would find plenty to obsess over.

Co-op got even warmer praise. The main game now supports up to four players online, up from two in the original. Jeremy Parish of 1Up.com named it the game's strength, and Official Xbox Magazine UK's Ben Talbot called it the best sandbox co-op "this side of Saints Row 2". In co-op you can also find special Online Orbs that boost all your skills, so there's a reward for playing together beyond the fun of it.

  • Four-player online co-op through the full campaign
  • Competitive modes for up to 16 players, including Rocket Tag, Vehicle Tag, Capture the Orb, Deathmatch and Team Deathmatch
  • Road and Rooftop checkpoint races
  • A new enemy type, the Freaks, who die in sunlight and can be fought with special UV weapons

The Daily Telegraph summed up the case for it with a 7 out of 10, calling it "immense fun" and crediting that to the core play being kept mostly as it was.

Where it falls short: a sequel critics called a rerun

That same point, that so little changed, is the main complaint against it. Nearly every outlet raised it. Ben Reeves of Game Informer said the game is almost indistinguishable from the first Crackdown, and he also faulted unfinished textures, mindless enemy AI and low replay value. Official Xbox Magazine UK, even while praising it, objected that Pacific City's layout was too close to the original.

Some reviews were harsher. Destructoid said the game "has no real reason to exist" and pointed to new problems the original didn't have. Metro UK gave it 6 out of 10 and called it "more expansion pack than sequel". Wired gave it 5 out of 10, arguing the design changes had removed the most fun parts and drawn attention to the weak ones.

Parish of 1Up.com put the split neatly: the best parts are the ones lifted from the first game, and the new additions range from annoying to infuriating.

Story was the other weak spot. IGN and GameTrailers both criticized the lack of a real story or structure. The A.V. Club, which gave it a B, pushed back and argued that games don't need to spell everything out. That's a minority view, but a fair one if you came for the rooftops rather than the plot.

The co-op catch you should know about

Co-op is the best reason to play, but it has a limit. Campaign missions only advance for the player hosting the game, so friends who join in don't move their own story forward. In a game with so little story, that matters less than it would elsewhere, but it means one person in the group gets the real progress.

Local network play is also gone. The original supported System Link for co-op, and this game doesn't. Microsoft producer Peter Connelly said adding it would have taken half a day of work for something only "a tiny percentage of gamers" would use. If you planned to set up two consoles in one house, check that first.

411Mania gave the clearest buying advice of any critic: fun if you love collecting things, but nothing new worth seeing if you've already finished the original. That holds up.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet