Crimson Dragon's rail sections won critics over; its open arenas lost them
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One critic's good time is another's slog
Destructoid's Chris Carter liked Crimson Dragon's gameplay and presentation. His only complaints were occasional camera trouble and the microtransactions. At the other end, Polygon's Justin McElroy was frustrated by the core shooting and by the systems around it. He wrote that the game turns riding a flying dragon into "a bland, frustrating slog."
Most critics landed between those two. Metacritic's average came out at 55 from 39 reviews, which it calls "mixed or average." The praise and the complaints point at specific parts of the game, so it's possible to tell which of them would matter to you.
The rails work and the open arenas don't
Crimson Dragon is a rail shooter set on the planet Draco. Its 26 levels are split into sections a few minutes long. You move an aiming reticle to shoot enemies and incoming projectiles. A lock-on attack hits several targets at once, a stronger attack has to be aimed by hand, and a dodge roll gets you out of trouble. Attacks are colored green or red to show how well they work against the selected target.
Most levels follow a fixed track, but boss fights happen in large open areas, and that is where reviews turned against it. GamesRadar's Ryan Taljonick praised the on-rails sections but faulted the free-roaming controls. IGN's Jose Otero made the same split, saying the open levels caused control problems the rail sections didn't have. GameSpot's Peter Brown called the camera controls off-putting, even though he liked the design and challenge of the later levels.
The more freedom the game hands you, the less critics liked it.
Revival gems and the difficulty wall
Between missions you raise your dragon with food and items gathered during play. There are six dragon types, each with fixed elemental powers, stats and skills, plus a different evolved form. Clearing stages earns in-game currency and experience. Revival gems can be found in play or bought with real-world money.
That purchase option drew the most consistent criticism. Edge liked the easier levels but said the difficulty spikes leave you two choices: replay earlier stages or pay. Jon Blyth of the UK edition of Official Xbox Magazine praised the gameplay and art design but faulted the microtransactions, the RPG elements and the short length. Several gaming sites also criticized the microtransactions outside their reviews, as part of wider player backlash against paid extras.
A look critics liked more than its graphics
The art split critics in an unusual way. Eurogamer's Martin Robinson praised the art direction while knocking its technical quality, then called the game "a thin and troubled tribute" to the Panzer Dragoon games. Game Informer's Ben Reeves disliked the art and graphics outright, along with the music, controls and shallow gameplay. Famitsu's four reviewers enjoyed the gameplay, but several mentioned low-quality graphics and control problems. One found the game monotonous for lack of variety.
Kinect and co-op are extras, not reasons to buy
You can steer and attack with body movements through the Kinect peripheral, and use voice commands to reposition or fire the special attack. GameTrailers' Rob Slusser enjoyed this support. He also felt the game lacked the content and polish to reach beyond a cult following.
Online features are light:
- asynchronous co-op lets players hire each other's dragons and share mission rewards;
- leaderboards post completion scores;
- an update added online play for up to two players.
Some missions open alternate paths on repeat runs, and optional objectives such as time limits or no-damage clears give you reasons to replay a stage.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Crimson Dragon en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q5185689 wikidata.org