Analysis · Cities: Skylines

Critics crowned it over SimCity, but it's calm and light on guidance

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A perfect score on one side, a warning on the other

The Escapist gave Cities: Skylines a perfect score and called it the "finest city builder" in over a decade, pointing to its low price as well. IGN liked it too, at 8.5, but told readers not to expect "exciting scenarios or random events." Most of the critical record sits between those two verdicts: a game praised for its depth and faulted for not throwing much at you.

The numbers lean firmly positive. Metacritic described the reception as "generally positive," and critic aggregates landed at 83/100 across the PC and console versions, with one aggregate at 86/100. The critic average of 8.4 is calculated from those critic aggregates.

The appeal is in the plumbing

You start with a 2-by-2-kilometre plot, an exit off a nearby highway, access to water and some starting money. You lay roads, zone residential, commercial and industrial areas, and run power, water and sewage so people move in and find jobs.

As the population passes set milestones, more tools open up:

  • schools, fire and police stations, health care and waste management
  • tax controls, government edicts and mass transit
  • districts, each with its own rules, such as agriculture-only industry, free public transport to cut traffic, or different tax rates

Buildings level up when their surroundings improve. A shop grows when nearby residents are better educated, so it hires more staff and pays more tax. That chain of cause and effect is what critics responded to. Destructoid gave it 9 out of 10, and its reviewer said the planning, building and nurturing drew out unusual creativity.

The map grows too. Once you have enough people and money you can buy neighboring plots, up to nine of the 25 tiles in a 10-by-10-kilometre area. The limit exists so the game runs on a wide range of PCs. Steam Workshop mods can open all 25 tiles, or the whole 81-tile map of 324 square kilometres.

Where it beat SimCity, and where it fell short

Critics compared it with SimCity at almost every turn. When Cities: Skylines was announced, journalists saw it as an answer to the poorly received 2013 SimCity reboot, one calling it "the antidote" to that game. Eurogamer pointed out a "size mismatch" between the two studios: Colossal Order had nine staff at the time. Even so, critics broadly decided the smaller studio had taken over the genre's top spot, and The Escapist rated it the better game in every category it compared.

The criticism was narrow but consistent. Some reviewers missed SimCity's disasters and random events, and others wanted a helpful, substantial tutorial. The first gap was later filled by the Natural Disasters DLC, which added disasters along with buildings that detect and respond to them. The tutorial complaint matters most for newcomers, who start with a lot of systems and little guidance.

If you need the game to set goals for you, the base game won't do much of that. If you like setting your own, that's the reason to buy it.

A simulation that real planners used

The best evidence for its depth comes from outside games. The city government of Stockholm used it to plan a new transportation system. The developer of Bus Simulator 18 laid out its world map's roads and highways in it first. A Polish YouTuber rebuilt an interchange planned near Kraków and showed it would cause congestion and heavy lane-switching. The Polish General Directorate for National Roads and Highways then ordered more analysis, confirmed the problems and had the interchange redesigned.

Researchers have also studied it as a teaching tool for subjects including real estate, environmental science and urban planning. It held up over time as well: in 2020, Rock, Paper, Shotgun ranked it the fourth best management game on PC, and it was nominated for Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year at the 19th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet