Analysis · Dragon Age: Origins

Critics forgave this 2009 BioWare epic its plain looks for its depth

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One of the deepest RPGs of its year, in plain clothes

Eurogamer's John Walker called the depth of Dragon Age: Origins one of the most extraordinary gaming achievements he had seen. On the other side, VideoGamer.com's Wesley Yin-Poole found its graphics boring and generic. He and GameSpy's Gerald Villoria both felt six years of development was too long for visuals that ordinary.

Both views hold up, and the scores show which one mattered more. The PC version has a 91 on Metacritic, with the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 versions at 87 and 86. That gap comes from differences in interface, graphical performance and online content delivery. It's the same game on every platform. The critic average of 9.1, computed from critic scores, lands in the same place.

Your origin decides how Ferelden treats you

You play a Grey Warden, one of an order of elite fighters sent to defeat the Archdemon and save the world from the Blight. First you pick a race (human, elf or dwarf) and a class (warrior, rogue or mage). That pair decides which of six origin stories opens the game: Dalish Elf, Dwarf Commoner, City Elf, Mage, Human Noble or Dwarf Noble.

The origin is more than a prologue. A Dwarf Commoner faces hatred and discrimination from other dwarves. Giant Bomb's Dave Snider said the way the game keeps referring back to each origin makes the world hang together. GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd felt the new ideas made a familiar setting of elves and dwarves feel new. The dissent came from IGN's Jeff Haynes, who called the world "rich and vivid" but found the origins inconsistent enough to make it less believable. Once the opening ends, all six paths merge into the same main plot.

Companions who argue back

The story's strength is its people. Snider said some choices stayed with him for weeks, and he singled out Claudia Black's Morrigan as one of the best performances in the game. VanOrd called the choices "momentous". GameSpy praised the lack of a morality system, which makes the characters feel more complex. Looking back at the 10th anniversary, USGamer's Eric Van Allen noted that most companions don't follow the Warden out of blind loyalty. The result, in his words, "reveled in the moral grays".

The plot underneath is less daring. Game Informer's Joe Juba called it good but predictable, standard fantasy at heart. GamesRadar found the opening generic, though the story grew more engrossing as it went on. GameRevolution's Nick Tan enjoyed the banter between companions as a lighter break.

Combat built around the pause button

Fights run in real time, but you can pause to queue orders, switch between characters, or pull the camera up to a top-down view where friends and enemies are color-coded. Companions follow rules you set in the Tactics menu. Health and stamina refill after every battle, and VanOrd said that choice kept the pace moving.

Snider's warning matters most: players who won't use the pause won't appreciate the game, because the fights ask for patience and strategy.

For players who will pause, the payoff is real. Snider and VanOrd both rated the boss battles highly, and Juba found plenty of room to experiment with skills. Tan ranked the system above other BioWare combat, with one odd complaint: characters can't step into water. Snider called the game a "real throwback" to the PC role-playing epics of years past.

Where 2009 shows, and where it doesn't

The looks were the weak spot. VanOrd liked the art style and some striking landmarks but not how the environments look from the top-down view. Villoria found it behind Mass Effect 2 visually, with facial animation that can look wooden, though he enjoyed the combat animation. Both he and Yin-Poole knocked the sex scenes, which GameSpy called "off-putting" and VideoGamer.com called "anticlimactic".

Length is no problem. GamesRadar estimated more than 80 hours of content. Villoria, Juba and Yin-Poole all said the six origins and the way companions react to your choices give it unusual replay value.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet