Analysis · Metroid Dread

Critics loved Metroid Dread's bosses and barely found a flaw to argue with

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The highest praise and the one real knock

The strongest praise on record comes from IGN, which said Metroid Dread pairs the series' classic exploration with "some of the best boss fights ever." The sharpest criticism is mild by comparison. Chris Carter of Destructoid called the game a masterful take on the Metroidvania formula, then added that it "doesn't take a lot of big swings."

That gap is the story of this game's reception. Critics found plenty to praise and very little to fault. The only pushback in the record is that Dread polishes a familiar idea rather than reinventing it. Carter's own image settles the point: it rarely hits "a foul ball."

On Metacritic, the Switch version scores 88 out of 100, which the site labels "generally favorable." the critic average of 8.7 is computed from critic aggregates by a published formula. It isn't a separate opinion of our own.

Boss fights are the main reason critics rate it so highly

Samuel Claiborn of IGN described a wide range of bosses. Some are the classic big monster with patterns and weak points to learn. Others are closer to a duel, with enemies that copy Samus's own moves, which he compared to Smash Bros. That range matters: a Metroidvania can pace itself through exploration, but its bosses are what players remember.

The combat underneath those fights builds on Metroid: Samus Returns (2017). Dread keeps that game's free aim and melee attacks, so the counter and the aimed shot are part of every encounter. Critics treated this as a strength. IGN singled out the game's "excellent modern combat" as a big part of why the classic formula still works.

Exploration keeps the old shape and adds more ways to move

The structure will be familiar to series fans. Samus explores the planet ZDR in side view, finds new items and weapons, and uses them to reach areas that were closed before. Upgrades come from Chozo statues and from destroying a Core-X, as in earlier games.

PJ O'Reilly of Nintendo Life praised the mix of returning mechanics and new ones, saying the game makes it feel like you always have plenty of choice in how to explore and get around. For a game this dependent on the map, that sense of freedom is high praise.

The game also rewards replays. Completion time, difficulty level and the percentage of items collected all add images to an in-game gallery, which gives fast or thorough players a reason to go again.

The E.M.M.I. chases are where patience gets tested

Dread's new idea is stealth. In certain areas, robots called E.M.M.I.s hunt Samus. The game asks you to hide, reduce your noise, and use the Phantom Cloak, a camouflage that makes Samus invisible but slows her down.

The rules are strict:

  • If an E.M.M.I. catches Samus, you get two narrow windows to land a melee counter and escape.
  • Miss both and Samus dies.
  • The only way to destroy one is the Omega Blaster, a temporary upgrade that is lost after a single kill.
  • Each kill earns a new permanent upgrade, so every robot cleared is progress.

If repeated instant failure wears on you, these zones are the part of Dread most likely to.

This is our reading of the design, not a complaint the critics in the record made. They didn't flag the chases as a problem. Still, a mechanic built on narrow timing windows and sudden death will suit some players far better than others.

Its place in the series and on the awards shelf

Dread is the ninth main Metroid game, following Metroid: Other M (2010), and a sequel to Metroid Fusion (2002). MercurySteam and Nintendo EPD made it, and it's a Switch exclusive. Joe Findly of CGMagazine called it "a wonderful, modern take" on a game from his childhood, which sums up how many critics saw it.

The awards backed that up. Dread won Best Action/Adventure Game at the Game Awards 2021 and Nintendo Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards, and both Time and Digital Trends named it Game of the Year. A game that "doesn't take a lot of big swings" collected a lot of trophies anyway.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet