Analysis · CrossfireX

CrossfireX added Remedy campaigns to a PC shooter and lost both halves

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A PC series comes to Xbox with a story attached

CrossfireX was the third installment in Smilegate's Crossfire series and the console version of Crossfire (2007), the PC shooter the series started with. It launched on February 10, 2022, on Xbox One and Xbox Series X and Series S, published by Xbox Game Studios and Smilegate.

The package came in two parts. The multiplayer was a free-to-play team shooter carried over from the PC original. The single-player portion was paid, and Remedy Entertainment, the studio behind Max Payne, Alan Wake and Control, worked on its two campaigns. Adding that story mode was the big change. Crossfire had always been a competitive shooter, and CrossfireX tried to make it something more.

It didn't last. The game was shut down on May 18, 2023, barely more than a year after launch.

What it kept: the PC original's objective-based team game

The multiplayer stayed close to the series' roots, and close to Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. Two hostile private military factions fought over objectives across three modes:

  • Classic: attackers try to plant a bomb while defenders try to stop them. Everyone carries standard weapons.
  • Spectre: the attackers are spectres armed only with knives, but they stay invisible while they stand still.
  • Modern: the two teams fight for control of two objective points on a map.

Keeping that format made sense for a series built on it, and Spectre mode was a smart twist on bomb defusal. But a console port depends on how the shooting feels with a controller, and that's where critics were harshest. IGN called the multiplayer's gunplay and controls "atrocious." A familiar list of modes can't carry a shooter when reviewers say the basic aiming and movement don't work.

What it changed: campaigns that didn't land

The single-player portion was the real departure. It was split into operations, each made up of several episodes, and two operations were available at launch. The story followed a global conflict between Black List and Global Risk, the same two factions that fought in multiplayer. The campaigns weren't free-to-play, and they're also part of Crossfire HD on PC in China.

On paper, a story mode with Remedy's involvement was the most interesting part of the package. Critics didn't see it pay off. IGN called the characters bland and criticized the storytelling, and Polygon criticized the pacing. A campaign that exists to give a multiplayer series some personality needs characters people remember, and reviewers didn't find any.

Critics found almost nothing to defend

The reviews were about as bad as it gets for a platform exclusive. Metacritic summed them up as "generally unfavorable" and listed CrossfireX as the second-worst game of 2022. Aggregate scores came in at 41/100 for each Xbox version (nine reviews each) and 42/100 across 31 reviews. A third figure sat at 3%. The critic average, worked out from those critic aggregates, is 4.2 out of 10.

What stands out is that neither half got away clean. Critics knocked the multiplayer for its controls and the campaigns for their characters and pacing, so no audience came away with a reason to stay.

A new story mode can't save a shooter whose shooting doesn't work.

Where to go instead

CrossfireX is offline, so this is a record of what happened, not something you can buy. If the Remedy connection caught your eye, the studio's own games are the better bet: Control and Quantum Break show what Remedy does when the story is the whole point. If you want to stay with the series, Crossfire Legion is the other Crossfire release from 2022.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet