Cuphead's boss fights won critics over until the last ones pushed too hard
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics split on where the difficulty stops being fair
No critic called Cuphead easy. The argument was about the last stretch. Destructoid's Brett Makedonski called the challenge "tough but fair." Ray Carsillo at EGMNow died 188 times and said it made him want to keep going, not quit. Two critics liked most of the game and then pulled back at the end. Polygon's Chris Plante wrote that the difficulty "eventually goes too far," and Colm Ahern of VideoGamer.com called the final bosses "a step too far."
That split tells you more than the scores, which are high across the board. The game is almost all boss fights, with run and gun levels in between. They're spread over four worlds and end with a three-phase fight against the Devil. If the early bosses feel like puzzles worth solving, critics suggest it's worth it to the end. If they already feel like a wall, the reviews say the wall gets taller.
Learning patterns or reacting fast depends on the critic
Makedonski said the fights depend on "exhaustive" pattern recognition and end up testing muscle memory more than reaction speed. PC Gamer's Chris Schilling disagreed: some random elements mean you can't just memorize a fight and repeat it. GamesRadar+'s Lucas Sullivan said the game asks for patience and pays it back "tenfold."
In practice, players who like to practice a fight until they get it right will have plenty to practice, and the randomness keeps it from becoming routine. Players who want one fixed routine they can run perfectly every time may find that variation annoying.
The game makes retrying easy. Lives are infinite, gear stays equipped after each death, and GameSpot's Peter Brown liked the quick loading that keeps trial and error moving. His complaint was that the game doesn't show how close you are to winning. IGN's Joe Skrebels pointed to that same missing health bar and called it the game's "most devilish" feature. Two critics looked at the same design and reacted in opposite ways.
The controls drew the sharpest disagreement
Schilling praised the "nimble and responsive" handling and a reliable jump and dash. Makedonski called the eight-direction aiming "clunky and awkward," and Skrebels criticized both the parry system and the control scheme. Plante liked the parry more than the attacks and called it "relatively forgiving."
The parry matters more than it first looks. You slap objects marked in pink to fill a super meter shown as five playing cards. One card pays for an enhanced attack. A full meter pays for a Super Art, and you earn each of the three Super Arts in a mausoleum challenge where you parry a horde of ghosts. A player who never gets comfortable with the parry gives up a big share of the game's damage.
If the parry clicks for you, much of the rest follows. If it doesn't, the later bosses will be harder than they need to be.
What critics agreed on, and what makes it easier
Critics agreed on the look and the music. They called the 1930s cartoon style "gorgeous" (EGMNow), a "masterwork" (IGN) and a "true recreation" of hand-drawn cel animation (GameSpot). Makedonski called the jazz soundtrack "similarly fabulous," and the album Selected Tunes from Cuphead later topped the Billboard jazz albums chart, the first video game to do so.
A few features make the game easier to get into:
- Every boss has a simple mode except the final two. You must win on regular mode to progress, and that opens expert mode for the level.
- Local co-op lets a second player join as Mugman. If one player dies, the other can bring them back by parrying their soul before it floats off the screen.
- The Delicious Last Course expansion adds a new area, new bosses and Ms. Chalice, who has a double jump, an invincible roll and a parry dash.
Note that last point about simple mode: the easier setting stops before the two final fights, which are the ones critics argued about. Cuphead is rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 7, and it runs on Windows, macOS, PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Cuphead en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q18149495 wikidata.org