Analysis · Digimon Story: Cyber Sleuth

Cyber Sleuth pairs 249 Digimon and striking art with old-school battles

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Famitsu's 34 out of 40 next to Destructoid's shrug

Japanese magazine Weekly Famitsu gave Digimon Story: Cyber Sleuth 34 out of 40, from individual scores of 8, 9, 9 and 8. Destructoid's sharpest complaint pointed the other way. It said the battle system is "basically everything you've seen before" from decades of Japanese role-playing games.

Both judgments fit the same game. Cyber Sleuth is a familiar RPG made with care, and how much the familiarity bothers you will decide most of what follows. Metacritic puts it at 75/100, which it labels generally favorable. The critic average of 7.6 is calculated from those critic aggregates. It isn't a separate verdict.

The roster is the reason to show up

You play a human who can command Digimon, digital creatures with their own abilities that fight other Digimon. You start by choosing Palmon, Terriermon or Hagurumon as your partner, and you pick up more as you reach new areas. The game has 249 unique Digimon in total. Seven of them came as DLC over the game's life, and two were exclusive to the Western release.

The game also respects the time you put into that collection. New Game Plus keeps:

  • all of your Digimon
  • non-key items and money
  • memory and sleuth rank
  • scan percentages and Digifarm progress

The Complete Edition adds the 92 new Digimon from Hacker's Memory, for 341 in all. PlayStation LifeStyle saw the gameplay improvements as a step in the right direction for fans waiting for the series to reach "Pokémon's level." The roster is where that step shows most clearly.

Where it shows its age

Critics agreed on the weak spots. Destructoid noted the random encounters and called them "either deliciously or inexcusably old-school," depending on the player. That's a fair warning: if constant interruptions on the way across a map wear you down, this game won't change your mind.

PlayStation LifeStyle went further and criticized the linear dungeon design and an interface it called "cheap." Hardcore Gamer said the story and script needed fine-tuning and the world needed to be more interesting. Those are three separate outlets landing on the same point. The structure around the collecting is plain, and the writing doesn't make up for it.

The more a game rests on old-school random battles, the more its dungeons and story need to carry the rest. Critics found that Cyber Sleuth's don't quite manage it.

Yasuda's art gave the series a face

PlayStation LifeStyle's strongest praise went to the colorful art and character design of Suzuhito Yasuda. It argued that his style gave life to a game series that had spent years struggling to establish its identity. That matters more here than usual. A collecting game with plain dungeons depends on its creatures and cast to keep you looking forward to what comes next.

The game's history explains why critics graded it as a turning point. It's the fifth game in the Digimon Story series, following 2011's Super Xros Wars, and the first released on home consoles. It reached North America on February 2, 2016. That made it the first in the series released there since 2007's Digimon World Dawn and Dusk, and the first released under its original title. Hardcore Gamer called it "a solid first step," and players seem to have agreed: it had sold over 800,000 copies worldwide by May 2019.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet