Dark Souls III makes every swing cost stamina and every death cost souls
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every swing spends stamina, so every swing is a choice
Fights come down to three meters: health, stamina and focus points (FP). Attacking, blocking and dodge-rolling all use stamina. Run out and your character is left open, so the game punishes button-mashing and rewards waiting for an opening. Weapons have standard and strong attacks, some attacks can be charged, and shields can block a hit or deflect it.
The new layer in this entry is weapon and shield Skills, special moves that change depending on what you're holding and that use FP. Spells, miracles and pyromancies draw from the same FP pool instead of a fixed number of casts. Healing works the same way. Estus Flasks restore health, Ashen Estus Flasks restore FP, and you decide how many uses go to each. A melee build can put nearly everything into healing, while a caster has to give some of it up to keep casting.
Critics noticed that combat and movement are faster than in Dark Souls II, and many linked that change to FromSoftware's work on Bloodborne. The defensive tools are still there, though. Shields didn't go away, so slower and more careful styles still work.
Death costs souls, and a second death costs them for good
Killing enemies earns souls, which are both your money and your experience points. If you die, the souls you're carrying stay where you fell. You can go back and pick them up, but if you die again on the way, they're gone. Bonfires are the checkpoints where you rest, and the trip from the last bonfire back to your souls is where most of the tension sits.
The loop is harsh but clear. A run that goes badly costs you progress you'd already earned, so every unfamiliar corridor feels like a gamble.
Fewer areas, bigger ones, and a straighter road
Dark Souls III has fewer areas than Dark Souls II, but they're larger, and many of them loop back to a bonfire through shortcuts you open along the way. That keeps the walk back after a death short, which matters in a game this hard.
This is where critics disagreed most. Some called the world less exploratory than earlier entries and more linear in its structure, and some saw the whole thing as familiar, with a perceived lack of surprise. Even the critics who said so mostly still praised the combat and the overall design. If finding your own way through a tangled map is what you loved about the first Dark Souls, expect a more guided route here.
Bosses and atmosphere carried the praise
Critics praised the atmosphere, the visual design, the combat and above all the boss encounters. You play the Ashen One, an unkindled warrior on a quest tied to the Lords of Cinder and the fading First Flame, and the dark fantasy setting gives that dying world a heavy, ruined feel. Series creator Hidetaka Miyazaki came back to direct after a supervisory role on Dark Souls II, and many critics called the result a fitting conclusion to the series.
Critics praised the bosses and the combat more than anything else, and even the reviewers who were tired of the formula praised them.
Technical issues showed up in the more critical reviews. Critic scores on PC, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One sit close together, between 87/100 and 89/100, so no version stands out as the one to avoid.
Builds and invasions keep it going, the first expansion less so
The character builder and range of weapons were made bigger to support more play styles, which gives a second character a real reason to exist. Online play from the earlier games returns. You can summon other players for co-op or get invaded by hostile ones, which puts unpredictable fights in places you thought you knew.
The first expansion, Ashes of Ariandel, got a cooler reception. Critics liked its new enemies, its bosses and its dedicated player versus player arena, but they faulted its short length. OpenCritic rated it "Fair", and 37% of critics recommended it, a long way from the 94% for the base game. Buy the base game first and treat the expansion as optional.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Dark Souls III en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20112508 wikidata.org