Darkest Dungeon II makes a party's nerves as dangerous as the road
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Favorable scores with a softer note at the low end
Critics liked this game, and they agreed with each other. One aggregate gives it 83/100 across 18 reviews, and that 83 holds for every version it lists: Windows, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X and Series S, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch. The bigger review pools land close by, at 81/100 from 78 reviews (January 29, 2025) and 82% from 80 reviews (February 17, 2025). Metacritic calls it "generally favorable."
The harshest number is a 75/100 from a smaller group of seven reviews. That's still a positive score, but it shows that some critics were less impressed than others. The published consensus doesn't list what those critics disliked, so read it as a difference in how much they liked the game, not a set of specific complaints. The critic average, computed from these critic aggregates, is 8.0 out of 10.
Stress is the system that decides a run
The basics are familiar. You build a party of heroes, each with their own strengths and abilities, give them trinkets and combat items, and drive a stagecoach toward a mountain that is the source of the evil spreading across the world. Places of interest and roadblocks along the way lead into turn-based fights. Positioning matters, because some skills can't be used when a hero is standing in the wrong spot.
Stress is what makes the game its own. Stress builds as the heroes press on. Push a hero too far and they have a meltdown in the middle of a fight, which takes a big chunk of their health and leaves them with negative traits. Stress also affects how the heroes get along:
- Heroes who are friendly with each other get extra perks.
- Heroes who resent each other can stop one another from using skills and push each other's stress higher.
This is the best idea in the game. A run can fall apart because the party turned on itself, not because an enemy hit too hard. That's harsh, but it keeps every fight from playing out the same way.
Every rest has a price
The game rarely gives anything away for free. Inns are where stress drops, relationships get repaired and a new hero can join after someone dies. But every stay at an inn also raises Loathing, a stat that tracks how far the world's evil has spread. Hospitals clear bad traits. Shrines of Reflection tell the characters' backstories.
The flame on the stagecoach stands for the party's hope, and the team takes penalties when it burns low. Put that together with Loathing and every choice to rest or keep going costs something either way.
Resting fixes the party and worsens the world. Pressing on does the opposite.
When a run ends, your Profile rank goes up and opens new characters and items for later attempts. That's the main thing that carries over between runs, so anyone who wants a lasting roster to build up will find the base game thin on that front.
Kingdoms brings back what the first game kept
That gap is what the free Kingdoms update, released in January 2025, goes after. It adds a new campaign and three enemy factions. Chris Bourassa, the game's director, said it would "blend" the permanence and roster management of the original Darkest Dungeon with this game's travel and combat.
Both of the larger review pools are dated weeks after Kingdoms arrived, and they sit at 81 and 82. So the scores most readers will see describe the game with this update included.
Players backed the game long before that. Darkest Dungeon II entered early access on Windows on October 26, 2021 and sold 100,000 copies on that first day. The full release came on May 8, 2023, and Red Hook Studios said it had passed 500,000 copies a week later.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Darkest Dungeon II en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q100899546 wikidata.org