Days Gone's hordes are thrilling, but the road between them runs long
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The horde fights are the reason to play
Most of Days Gone is about staying alive. You play Deacon St. John, a former outlaw biker turned drifter and bounty hunter, two years after a pandemic turned millions of people into Freakers. They sleep through the day and come out at night to roam, feed and gather in groups. Get caught in the open by a big group and you're overwhelmed fast, so the game keeps pushing you to keep your distance and plan ahead.
You get plenty of tools for that. You can sneak up and kill with a combat knife, fit suppressors to firearms so shots don't draw a crowd, and use survival vision to highlight nearby enemies and useful items. Proximity mines, grenades, crafted molotov cocktails and narrow choke points do the heavy work. You can even lead Freakers into human enemies and let the two groups fight.
Critics kept coming back to the horde fights. Game Informer's Matthew Kato called them "terrifying" and "tense" and praised enemy behavior that's unpredictable enough that two attempts can go very differently. GameSpot's Kallie Plagge found them "exhilarating", but said campaign missions that stack horde clears nearly back to back wear you out.
The quieter parts landed less well. Reviewers widely called the stealth basic and dull, and VentureBeat's Dean Takahashi found the shooting clunky, pointing out that you can't fire backward while Freakers chase you.
A motorcycle you have to keep alive
Deacon's bike is how you get almost everywhere, and it needs looking after. It burns fuel, breaks down when it takes too much damage, and you repair it with scrap you collect. Refueling happens at gas stations and camps. Fast travel also uses fuel and lets time pass, and it only opens up once you've destroyed every Freaker nest between the two points.
Earning trust with the settlement camps gets you camp credits, which buy weapons, supplies and bike parts that improve speed, durability and handling. GamesRadar's Leon Hurley said all that upkeep slowly made him fond of the bike. Other reviewers felt the opposite. To them, the constant refueling was a major source of tedium and a reason not to explore at all.
The bike is the clearest split in how critics saw the game: for some it gave the world its texture, for others it was the chore that kept them on the main road.
An open world that remembers but repeats
The map has a long list of side jobs: clearing Freaker nests, rescuing hostages, wiping out enemy camps, catching bounty targets and restoring power to NERO checkpoints. Those checkpoints hold injectors that permanently raise Deacon's health, stamina and focus (focus lets you slow time while aiming). Experience from missions unlocks skills for melee, ranged weapons and survival, and both Takahashi and Hurley liked feeling Deacon get steadily stronger.
The problem is variety. Kato called most side objectives filler, and Eurogamer's Malindy Hetfeld said you spend hours doing "the exact same thing" the same way. Hurley found the design entertaining but unoriginal. Several reviewers said the locations lack a strong look or backstory, so exploring them felt pointless.
Shacknews's Bill Lavoy pointed to one real strength. The world keeps track of what you've done, so a horde you wipe out stays gone and the area really is safer afterward. He also noted that the map is fairly small and that the game uses obstacles to force long detours.
Story and polish hold it back
Deacon is searching for his wife Sarah, who he thought was dead but may still be alive. Critics were divided on how well that story works. Takahashi found it engaging and called Deacon an "interesting and flawed character", though some story threads are never resolved. The Verge's Andrew Webster called it bland and struggled to connect with Deacon. Plagge called Deacon "selfish" and felt the story mostly exists to justify him. Some reviewers said it improves as more characters and emotional moments arrive. Others found it too long and missions lacking real consequences. Witwer's performance as Deacon was generally praised.
The technical side drew the most consistent complaints. Kato said the game lacks the polish of Sony's other first-party games. Takahashi pointed to bugs and an unstable frame rate, and the frequent loading screens between play and cutscenes were widely criticized.
Metacritic rates the PlayStation 4 version "mixed or average" and the later Microsoft Windows release "generally favorable". On OpenCritic, 54% of critics recommended the original game. The critic average, calculated from 19 critics, is 6.7 out of 10. That fits a game with a great core idea surrounded by a lot of routine.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Days Gone en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24576564 wikidata.org