Analysis · Dead or Alive Xtreme 2

Dead or Alive Xtreme 2 looks sharp but critics found little fun on its beach

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Strong visuals, weak fun

The best thing critics said about Dead or Alive Xtreme 2 and the worst thing came from the same review. TeamXbox's Dale Nardozzi praised its impressive graphics, its range of activities and its artistry. He also wrote that the game is "simply not fun to play." He scored it 6.7 out of 10, well down from the 9.2 he gave the first Xtreme.

Most other critics landed in the same place. GameRankings put the game at 54% and Metacritic at 53 out of 100 across 46 reviews of the Xbox 360 version. One other score on file is a kinder 30/40. Critics were happy with how the game looked and much less happy with how it plays.

The vacation loop is the real game

Like Dead or Alive Xtreme Beach Volleyball before it, this sequel is built around a two-week island vacation. Each day has a morning, an afternoon and an evening, and you pick one activity for each. You play as one of nine women from the series. Kokoro is the newcomer, since she wasn't in the first Xtreme.

Most of the structure revolves around friendship. You build bonds with the other women by buying them gifts from the island's shops and by playing pool-hopping and butt battles with them. Gifts have to suit the person getting them. Every character has likes and dislikes, and each has a favorite color that affects how she feels about an item and even the paper it's wrapped in. Players who like managing relationships get a lot of small details to track. Players who came for sport will see that the schedule leaves less room for it.

Volleyball got harder, not better

Volleyball is still the main event: two-on-two matches to 7 points, played with a partner. The controls still use just two buttons, pass/block and bump/spike. The difference is that players no longer move themselves into the best formation, so you have to position them by hand. That was meant to add challenge and variety. Critics mostly felt the result was a noticeably harder game that wasn't any more rewarding.

Two changes respond to complaints about the first game:

  • The camera was adjusted to fix criticism that it moved erratically or too often.
  • Online play lets two people face off over Xbox Live, each with a computer-controlled partner.

The trade-off is significant. The offline two-player Exhibition mode is gone, so playing volleyball against a friend means going online.

New minigames lean on luck

The new activities are where the sequel tries hardest to set itself apart from the first game, and they're also where critics were least impressed. IGN's Hilary Goldstein said the Butt Battle and Tug-of-War depend heavily on luck. Winning comes down to pressing a button at an arbitrary moment and guessing what your opponent will do next.

Jet ski racing is the exception critics noted. It's a new mode that has been compared to the Wave Race series, and it can be played offline or over Xbox Live. Apart from volleyball, it's the only activity with online multiplayer. Everything else is single-player.

Recycled animations and wobbly physics

Many reviewers thought the game was too much like its predecessor. Their main evidence was that many of the characters' animations came from the original and were only tweaked to work on the new engine. For a full-price sequel on new hardware, that hurt.

The new breast physics drew the harshest criticism. Some reviewers described the motion as independent and constant, continuing even when a character is standing still, which made some scenes awkward. Elisa Moses from X-Play called the effect "comical and a little creepy." The game's age ratings, Mature 17+ and PEGI 12, show how differently raters read the same content.

A sequel that adds activities without making them more fun gives you more to do, not a better game.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet