Demon's Souls charges a price for every death, and critics called it fair
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every swing costs stamina, and every death costs souls
Fights in Demon's Souls depend on timing. You choose when to strike, when to block and when to back off, and nearly everything you do drains a stamina meter. An empty meter leaves you open, so managing it is central to every fight. Different weapon types give you different moves, and they also change how fast your character moves.
Killing enemies earns Souls, and Souls do two jobs: they raise your stats, and they buy weapons, armor and items. Each stat increase costs more Souls than the last, so progress slows as you go.
Death is where the game shows its teeth. You go back to the start of the level, every regular enemy comes back, and you return in soul form with lower maximum health and none of your unspent Souls. Reach the bloodstain where you fell and you get them back. Die before you get there and they're gone for good. That one rule makes every trip through a level tense, because a careless death can wipe out a long stretch of progress.
A hub, five worlds and a free choice of route
You make your adventurer at the start, choosing sex and appearance, and some of those choices affect your stats. Your starting class shapes your stats too, but it isn't permanent. You can reshape the character later, and a new weapon can make it play like a different class.
The Nexus is the hub between levels. There you spend Souls, store items and travel between regions. Five worlds branch off it. Each is split into three areas, except World 1, which has four, and every area ends in a boss. Beating a boss leaves an Archstone, a point you can return to later.
After the first part of the opening region, you can take the other regions in any order. That helps when one boss won't fall: you can go somewhere else, gather Souls and gear, and come back stronger. A system called World and Character Tendency also governs several mechanics, so how you play affects what you find.
Other players turn up as ghosts, notes and invaders
With a PlayStation Network connection, you share each level with other players without seeing them directly. Brief ghosts of other players appear and can point out hidden passages or switches. Bloodstains left by other players replay their last moments, so you can see what killed them. Players can also leave pre-written messages on the floor that warn of traps, flag safe spots or suggest tactics for a boss.
- Co-op: up to three characters can team up in one host's world. Visitors stay in soul form until a boss dies.
- Invasions: a player can enter your world as a Black Phantom to fight you. If the Phantom wins, it gets its body back. If it loses, you take some of its Souls and it drops an experience level.
Critics singled this design out. GameZone called it "innovative", and Game Revolution said it makes a solitary game "surprisingly communal." GameSpot gave it Best Original Game Mechanic for the online integration, and X-Play named the multiplayer its Best Gameplay Innovation. Since all of this depends on the network, it's the part of the game most tied to its online setup.
Critics mostly agreed the difficulty was the point
The North American release averaged 89/100 at Metacritic, and many reviewers counted the high difficulty in its favor. GameSpot called it "fair" and said the combat "feels just right" once you learn each enemy. Edge argued that gaming's sharpest thrills come from its hardest lessons. In Eurogamer, Keza MacDonald described the relief of finally beating a boss that once killed her within half a minute as "the purest kind of gaming thrill."
Famitsu's 29 out of 40 shows the split: one editor gave it a 9 and another a 6.
At Famitsu, Paint Yamamoto praised a game you learn by losing. Maria Kichiji called it "far too stoic" and said it isn't for everybody. Official U.S. PlayStation Magazine liked the game but recommended it only for the "most masochistic" players. Taken together, critics broadly agreed the game is good. They disagreed about how many people would put up with it.
Dark fantasy looks with a few rough edges
Critics praised the presentation too. GamesRadar called it "graphically stunning", and GameTrailers said it "nails the dark fantasy look" and singled out a score played on real instruments. GameTrailers also flagged "jittery" physics, the most specific technical complaint critics raised.
The game's reputation outlasted its launch year. GameSpot named it its 2009 Overall Game of the Year, and in 2015 Edge ranked it 20th on its list of the greatest video games of all time.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Demon's Souls en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1153708 wikidata.org