Demon's Souls on PS5 left critics arguing only over how much they loved it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics split on degree, never on direction
Critics barely disagreed about Demon's Souls. The widest gap in the aggregate scores runs from 84/100 across 13 reviews to 92/100 for the PlayStation 5 version. OpenCritic found that 99% of critics recommended it, and Metacritic logged "universal acclaim."
The closest thing to dissent is a hedge. GameSpot opened its praise with "quirks aside" before calling the remake "an unmitigated success" and "a technical tour de force." Those quirks don't add up to a shared complaint across reviews, and the lower 84 comes with no clear case against the game.
So the useful split isn't between critics. It's between the game and a certain kind of player, and the same quality critics praised most is what divides them.
The praised difficulty is also the warning label
IGN credited the remake with keeping the "relentless challenge" and puzzle-like boss fights that made the original a landmark. The Souls series is known for being hard, and Bluepoint said the remake would not add difficulty levels. Nothing here can be turned down.
When every critic praises a game for being hard, that praise is a promise to fans of hard games and a warning to everyone else.
For players who like learning a boss through repeated deaths, that's the whole pitch. For players who bounced off earlier Souls games, the record offers no sign this one bends. The quality-of-life changes smooth out the original's annoyances, not its difficulty.
What the remake changes from the 2009 game
IGN said the remake plays "significantly better" than it did on the PS3, partly because of smart changes that modernize the original's most frustrating parts. The changes on record:
- Grains, new items that give temporary resistance to poison, fire and bleeding.
- Reworked carry weight. Moon grass healing items now weigh more the better they heal, from 0.1 for crescent moon grass to 6.0 for dark moon grass.
- Stockpile Thomas can take excess items, so you don't have to drop gear and risk losing it for good.
- Fractured World, a mirror mode that flips the layout of each area.
- A photo mode that pauses the game, which the original couldn't do. Its filters work during play too, including a "classic mode" look meant to recall the PS3 version.
- Expanded character creation with more customization options.
The carry-weight change cuts both ways. Stockpile Thomas removes a real source of loss, but the strongest healing items now cost far more of your carrying limit, so stocking up takes more planning.
Critics were warmest about the look. GameSpot called the game a showpiece for the PS5, and IGN called it "breathtakingly gorgeous."
A museum tour for Dark Souls fans
Game Informer saw a second audience. Demon's Souls, first made by FromSoftware for the PlayStation 3 in 2009, came before the Dark Souls games, and the outlet likened the remake to walking through an interactive museum. It pointed to early versions of Blighttown, the Pursuer and other series staples.
That makes it worth playing for anyone who finished Dark Souls and wants to see where its ideas started. It also carries some history of its own. It was Japan Studio's last game before the team became part of Team Asobi, and Bluepoint's final game before the studio shut down in 2026. It's only on the PlayStation 5, where it was a launch title on November 12, 2020.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Demon's Souls (2020 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q96227146 wikidata.org