Detective Pikachu's talking lead wins critics, but its cases rarely push back
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
An 8.2 from IGN, a 33% recommend rate overall
The best praise came from IGN, which gave Detective Pikachu 8.2 out of 10 and called it "a bold take on the iconic Pokemon." The harshest criticism came from several critics who said the story would work better as a film than as a game. That complaint shows up in the aggregates. OpenCritic counted 62 reviews and found that only 33% of critics recommended it, while its average across 61 reviews was 72/100.
Both sides can be right. The praise is about the character and the world. The criticism is about what the player actually does from one scene to the next. The game is strong on the first and thin on the second.
Pikachu carries the case
Critics kept coming back to the lead. IGN credited the "Pika Prompts", short exchanges that build Pikachu into more than a detective stereotype. It also called the game's fun mysteries and "wonderful coffee-loving lead" its biggest strengths. Ryan Craddock of Nintendo Life gave it 8 out of 10 and praised the art, the storytelling and a "genuinely likable cast" for showing the Pokémon world in a new light.
Reviewers also singled out the visuals, which more than one called "gorgeous". For a spin-off on the Nintendo 3DS, that's a clear win. The appeal is spending time in a city where Pokémon live alongside people, with a gruff, caffeinated Pikachu as your guide.
The detective work is gentle by design
You play as Tim Goodman, who teams up with Detective Pikachu to solve a run of mysteries. Each case asks you to:
- walk around a scene looking for clues,
- question people and Pokémon for new information,
- piece what you've found into an answer.
This is where the praise starts to come with conditions. Even in his positive review, Craddock noted the game is quite easy and gives no real penalty for wrong decisions. A detective game where a bad guess costs nothing turns deduction into a formality. Eurogamer compared it to the Ace Attorney series and said it feels closer to the Pokémon anime than to earlier Pokémon video games. That helps explain the film complaint: the story leads, and the player follows.
The age rating is Everyone, and the low difficulty makes more sense for younger players and newcomers to the genre. For them, a game that keeps the story moving is a plus.
Where the scores and awards land
The numbers show a game critics liked more than they recommended:
- One critic aggregate puts it at 78/100 across 10 reviews.
- OpenCritic averages 72/100 across 61 reviews, with 33% of critics recommending it.
- The critic average, calculated from those aggregates, is 7.5 out of 10.
It also earned recognition beyond reviews. It was nominated for "Nintendo Game of the Year" at the Golden Joystick Awards and for "Game, Franchise Family" at the National Academy of Video Game Trade Reviewers Awards. On North America's NPD charts, it was the top-selling 3DS game in March 2018.
The rule of thumb: buy it for Pikachu and the world. Don't buy it for the puzzles.
A long road to a worldwide release
Creatures developed the game, and Nintendo and The Pokémon Company published it. A shorter download-only version, Great Detective Pikachu: Birth of a New Duo, came out in Japan in February 2016. The full game followed worldwide on March 23, 2018, and reached Australia a day later. If you still have a 3DS, this is the version to get. It's a single-player game, best played in short sittings as a story you watch unfold.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Detective Pikachu (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q22635280 wikidata.org