Analysis · Devil May Cry: HD Collection

Devil May Cry HD Collection still grades every fight from D to S

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every fight ends with a letter grade

Moment to moment, the game is about keeping a fight going well. Dante, a demon hunter, faces groups of demons, and the player tries to stretch chains of attacks as long as possible, avoid taking hits, throw in taunts and keep switching moves. Repeating one combo isn't enough. The game wants variety, and it's keeping score.

That score is a rank from D to S. Stylish combat counts toward it, and so do how long a mission took, how many currencies were collected and how many consumables were used. Burning through healing items to get past a boss lowers the grade, even if the boss goes down.

Critics called this design innovative. They credited the series with starting a subgenre of "extreme combat" action games, where a powerful hero cuts through hordes of enemies with flair, and with being the first to capture the quick, free-flowing feel of classic 2D action games. Reviews of later games such as God of War, Chaos Legion and Blood Will Tell were judged against it.

The ranking is what keeps you replaying, not the plot

A system that grades time, pickups and item use as well as style turns every finished mission into a target to beat. Clearing a level and earning an S on it are two separate goals, and much of the game's lasting value lives in the gap between them. It's a single-player game with no other modes, so that personal chase is the long-term draw.

The story gets weaker marks. Critics were mixed on the series' writing:

  • A Gamecritics.com reviewer found the original's story too short and its characters thin.
  • Reviewers noted that Dante's trademark cockiness was mostly missing from Devil May Cry 2.
  • Devil May Cry 3 got the warmest response, with critics finding the relationships among its cast stronger than in Hideki Kamiya's original.

So come for the fighting. The cutscenes are the connective tissue, and critics didn't think much of them.

The early games carry real standing

The series' early entries have a strong reputation outside this collection. In 2010, IGN ranked Devil May Cry 42nd and Devil May Cry 3 18th on its list of the top 100 PlayStation 2 games. Two placings on one list shows how highly critics rated the series' start.

That standing explains why a collection still sells. Hideki Kamiya created the series and Hideaki Itsuno took over for every game after the first until Devil May Cry 5, and the combat grading that critics praised runs through the series from the start.

Two releases, and critics cooled on the second

The collection first came out on March 22, 2012, on PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 in Japan, then reached the United States on March 29, 2012. It returned on March 13, 2018, on Microsoft Windows, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One.

The scores tell a mixed story:

  • One aggregate gives 72/100 for every version, from 10 reviews.
  • A separate aggregate dated April 5, 2018, counted 45 reviews and landed at 65/100.

The critic average of 6.9 out of 10 is calculated from those critic aggregates, not given by our desk. It sits where the numbers do: well short of the praise the series earns as a whole, but nowhere near a failure. The fair reading is that critics respected what the games do and saw less reason to pay full price for them again.

It's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 16, so it isn't one for younger players.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet