Analysis · Don't Starve

Don't Starve rewards patient players and punishes everyone else

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who like being left alone with a problem

Don't Starve is built for the player who wants to be dropped somewhere hostile with no instructions and figure it out by failing. Klei Entertainment released it on April 23, 2013, and it has one goal: survive as many days as you can in a randomly generated world. A counter on screen tracks the days, and each one lasts 8 minutes of real time.

That player gets plenty here. Critics agreed the game is hard and never explains itself. IGN's Marty Sliva wrote that it will "never, ever hold your hand" and said he both loved and hated it for that. Official PlayStation Magazine's Leon Hurley argued that the learning is half the fun.

Players who want steady progress, a save to fall back on or a guided start will find a lot to resent. Most of the critical split comes down to which of those groups you're in.

Day and night play like two different games

By day you gather food, firewood and other materials, find crafting recipes, and build shelter, weapons and tools like axes. Almost every tool breaks with use. Food spoils, and eating spoiled food costs health and sanity while filling you up less.

At night, monsters come out, and so does Charlie, an unseen threat that attacks whenever the screen goes dark. You need a light source or night vision to keep it away. The seasons shift the balance: in winter, days get shorter and nights longer.

Critics liked how many odd ways there are to die. GameSpot's Nathan Meunier pointed to subzero winter temperatures as a wrinkle that adds depth. Joystiq's Jessica Conditt praised the number of threats and the clear display of health, hunger and mental stability. GamesRadar's Giancarlo Saldana said the unfamiliar monster designs keep you wary.

Where permadeath stops being fun

Death is permanent unless you've found rare or costly items such as the Meat Effigy, Touch-Stone or Life-Giving Amulet. Little carries over between runs: experience points (20 per day survived, paid out when you die) and the characters they earn you. Wilson is the default. Willow costs 160 points, and Woodie, the last character you can earn this way, needs the cap of 1,600. Each character has a perk and a drawback.

This is where reviewers disagreed most. Game Informer's Jeff Marchiafava usually likes permadeath, but he said a death here hurts more than in The Binding of Isaac or Spelunky because a run lasts so much longer. Meunier said the thrill fades when you're repeating "the same menial tasks" to win back lost ground. Sliva described about 30 minutes of boredom at the start of later runs and blamed some deaths on the camera hiding objects he needed.

The early game is the price of every new attempt. If that sounds like a chore, it will become one.

Saldana took the other side. He argued that each death still teaches you how things work, so progress comes in small, satisfying steps.

The look is the one thing nobody argued about

The art drew near-universal praise. Sliva admired the paper-cutout style and the way its gothic look makes ordinary objects feel threatening. Marchiafava said the cartoony art makes exploring a joy, and the Toronto Sun's Steve Tilley called it "whimsical and wonderful." Sliva compared the music to carnival tunes and found it catchy but short on variety. Saldana called it eerie yet calming.

The game was a finalist for the grand prize and for Excellence in Design at the 2014 Independent Games Festival, with honorable mentions for visual art and audio.

PC scored highest, but the console ports hold up

The PC release averaged 86/100 across 15 critic reviews. The Switch, Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Windows listings each sit at 75/100, but each is based on only three reviews. The critic average of 8.1 out of 10 is calculated from those critic scores.

On PlayStation 4, Destructoid's Jordan Devore said the game looked and played well, apart from some pixelation when the view zooms in on the inventory. He found a gamepad less efficient than a keyboard but still enjoyable. If you'd rather not survive alone, Don't Starve Together, the standalone multiplayer expansion, became free for existing owners on June 3, 2015.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet