Doom pays out health and ammo for charging straight at demons
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fight is where health comes from
Doom's 2016 reboot rests on one rule: the player attacks first. Health and ammo don't come from hiding behind cover. Demons that take enough damage stagger into a stunned state, and a short melee finisher called a Glory Kill pays out health. If there's enough fuel, the chainsaw kills an enemy outright and drops ammunition. Weapons never need reloading. Every system pushes the player toward the next enemy, not away from it.
Most critics bought it. Zack Furniss of Destructoid doubted the Glory Kill at first and came round to the view that it fit the flow of play. Giant Bomb's Brad Shoemaker called it "an essential part of the give-and-take" of the combat. Kyle Orland of Ars Technica saw a problem: the brief animation takes control away, which can leave a player disoriented or badly placed when it ends. In a game this fast, losing control for even a second costs something.
The arsenal supports the rule. The chainsaw, the super shotgun and the BFG 9000 return from the first two games, and mods earned during the campaign change how each gun behaves. Enemies are aggressive and quick on their feet, so standing still doesn't work.
Thirteen levels that reward a detour
The campaign runs 13 levels. The player is the Doom Slayer, fighting through an energy-mining facility on Mars and then Hell itself. Levels branch into multiple paths and open areas, and double-jumps and ledge climbing make vertical routes part of the map. Off the main path sit secrets, equipment upgrades, Doom marine figurines and data files about the setting. Each level also hides a lever that opens an area taken from a classic level of the original games.
Exploration could slow the forward push, but critics found that it feeds the combat instead. Arthur Gies of Polygon liked hunting for secrets because they tie into the upgrade system, and better gear makes the fights go better. His complaint was that the game sometimes closes off parts of a level without warning. That punishes anyone who left a secret for later.
An arcade mode, added on October 20, 2016, gives players every campaign upgrade from the start. It suits anyone who wants the combat without the backtracking.
A score built for the pace
Praise for the soundtrack was close to unanimous. Peter Brown of GameSpot called it "impactful", Jordan Pearson of Vice singled it out, and Sam White in The Daily Telegraph praised it along with the weapon design and the performance on every platform. James Davenport of PC Gamer called it "one of the best" of 2016. It also won Best Music / Sound Design at The Game Awards 2016.
In a game that wants constant motion, music that sets the tempo does real work. Mike Henriquez of GameRevolution said the same about the visual and art design, calling it "top-notch". Brown summed up the wider case: the reboot captures the spirit of the older games while refining them with modern elements.
Multiplayer drops the idea that makes the campaign work
The online side offers Team Deathmatch, Freeze Tag, Soul Harvest, Warpath, Clan Arena and Domination. Players choose a loadout of two weapons, pick up one-use "hack modules" that reveal information such as power-up timers, and grab runes that briefly turn them into demons like the Revenant, Baron of Hell and Mancubus.
Reviews were mixed:
- IGN's Joab Gilroy called Doom "a tale of two very different shooters" and said the multiplayer didn't match the campaign.
- Matt Buchholtz of Electronic Gaming Monthly criticized how the network handled latency.
- Edwin Evans-Thirlwell of Eurogamer called Warpath "memorable" and found the other modes underdeveloped.
- Julian Benson of Kotaku found it very similar to other shooters of the time.
- On the other side, David Houghton of GamesRadar+ called it "endlessly playable", and Eurogamer's Jon Denton also praised it.
Fixed loadouts replace the campaign's system of earning health and ammo by attacking, which helps explain why several critics found the multiplayer ordinary.
SnapMap is easy to pick up and hard to stretch
SnapMap lets players build single-player levels and co-op or competitive maps from the game's own assets. Players can place any enemy except the campaign bosses and adjust its AI and stats, or let the AI conductor fill a map automatically. Finished maps can be shared, rated and remixed by other players.
Critics praised how simple it is and regretted the limit to in-game assets. Matt Bertz of Game Informer liked how accessible it is but pointed to the small range of settings and the limits compared with a traditional community mod.
The Nintendo Switch port, released November 10, 2017, scored 79 on Metacritic, against 85 to 87 for the other versions. Nintendo Life still praised it in its review.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Doom (2016 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q513867 wikidata.org