Analysis · Dota 2

Dota 2's depth wins critics over, but its learning cliff splits them

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The split is about the first hundred matches, not the game

Few reviewers doubted that Dota 2 is good. The arguments were about whether it's worth what it asks of a new player. Aggregate scores sit at the top of the scale: 91/100 across 17 reviews, and 95/100 across three reviews of the Windows version. The critic average, which is calculated from those critic aggregates, is 9.1 out of 10.

Even reviewers who liked it warned about getting started. Benjamin Danneberg of GameStar called the curve a "learning cliff" and found the new tutorial only partly helpful. Fredrik Åslund of Gamereactor's Swedish edition gave a moderately positive review, praising the game's stability, but described his first match as one of the most humiliating of his gaming career. A review for Metro said the game hadn't fixed the steep start that Defense of the Ancients was known for.

On the other side, PC Gamer's Chris Thursten called the play "deep and rewarding," and Eurogamer's Quintin Smith described it as the form of the MOBA that every rival was chasing. Both sides are describing the same game. The depth that thrills one reviewer is what buries a newcomer in the first few matches.

Why the depth is real

A match is two teams of five, the Radiant and the Dire, fighting to destroy the other side's Ancient, a large structure inside each base. Three lanes connect the bases, guarded by towers and crossed by waves of computer-controlled creeps. That much is easy to grasp. The layers on top of it are where the complexity comes from:

  • 127 heroes, each with at least four unique abilities and an ultimate that becomes available at level six.
  • A drafting phase in which a picked hero is gone for everyone else, so the lineup itself is part of the strategy.
  • Cores who start weak and grow into match-winners, and supports who trade damage for healing and other buffs.
  • Mana, cooldowns, three attributes and a Talent Tree, all shaping how a hero grows across 30 levels.

PC Gamer's T. J. Hafer said the game is "all about counterplay," with most heroes designed to answer another. That's why critics kept praising its balance. It's also why a new player can lose without understanding why.

Where Valve earned credit beyond the match

The business model drew some of the warmest praise. IGN's Phill Cameron and Hardcore Gamer's James Kozanitis both pointed out that the store sells only cosmetic items, while League of Legends charges for heroes. Kozanitis went as far as calling it the only free-to-play game done right. Hafer also preferred that every hero is open to every player from the first match.

GameSpot's Martin Gaston rated its interface, voice acting and characterization above its competitors. Later additions won praise too: the 2016 virtual reality spectating mode impressed Polygon's Ben Kuchera, PC Gamer and Ars Technica.

The problems critics didn't let slide

Two complaints go beyond difficulty. The first is the community. In 2019, a report from the Anti-Defamation League found that up to 79% of players said they'd been harassed in some way, the highest figure on its list. Gamereactor and Metro both named player attitudes as part of what makes the start so hard.

The second is gambling. Ars Technica's Peter Bright criticized third-party sites that let players bet skins and wager on match results, often in places where underage players could take part. Valve's Erik Johnson said the company would act against those sites, since the practice broke its user agreements.

The record backs both claims: this is one of the most rewarding games critics have reviewed, and one of the least welcoming to new players.

Who that disagreement points to

CNET's Jason Parker put it simply: Heroes of the Storm is easier to get into, but Dota 2's depth pays off for players who put in the time to master it. That's the real dividing line. If you have a regular group of four friends, enjoy studying matchups and can shrug off a hostile teammate, the critics who loved it are describing your game. If you want short, low-stakes sessions, the critics who struggled are describing what you'll run into.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet