Analysis · Dr. Luigi

Dr. Luigi's best mode is the borrowed one, not the L-shaped pill gimmick

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The best-liked mode is old and the new one split critics

Polygon's Ben Kuchera called Virus Buster "a more direct, intuitive way to control the game." GameSpot's Heidi Kemps called Operation L, the mode built around the game's one new idea, "a disappointment." That pairing sums up Dr. Luigi. The part critics liked most was borrowed from Dr. Mario Online Rx, and the part that was meant to make this game its own left reviewers divided.

The numbers land in the middle. Dr. Luigi scored 65/100 on Metacritic across 38 reviews, and only 30% of critics on OpenCritic recommended it. Its critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 6.8 out of 10. The game still sold: in its first week in Europe it was the top seller on the Wii U eShop.

The basics haven't changed since the series began. You steer Luigi's two-color capsules into a bottle full of viruses. Line up four or more of the same color, vertically or horizontally, and they vanish. Clear every virus to finish the level, and the game ends if the capsules stack to the top.

Operation L trades precision for a new kind of planning

In Operation L, capsules come joined in an L shape and fall more slowly. Critics couldn't agree on whether that was enough:

  • Kemps found the shape too big to place exactly where you want it.
  • IGN's Scott Thompson expected a "shallow gimmick" but ended up enjoying it more than classic Dr. Mario.
  • Game Informer's Mike Futter often switched to Retro Remedy instead, partly because the randomly generated Operation L levels got hard.
  • Eurogamer's Chris Schilling liked how simply it plays and that the punishing difficulty is optional.
  • Jens Bischoff of 4Players called it practically the only reason to buy the game, and not reason enough at US$15.

The split makes sense. A bigger piece changes how you plan a board, but it also takes away the fine control that makes classic Dr. Mario satisfying. If you enjoy working around an awkward shape, Operation L adds something. If the appeal for you is placing each capsule exactly, it gets in the way, and Retro Remedy offers the traditional rules without the gimmick.

Virus Buster is the reason to own it

Virus Buster has you turn the Wii U GamePad sideways and drag capsules into place on the touchscreen. Of all the modes, it got the warmest reviews.

Kuchera picked it as his favorite and praised its steady climb in difficulty. Thompson liked its laid-back pace and calmer music, a less stressful option than the other modes. Futter enjoyed how it changes the rhythm of play while keeping the same rules. Kemps thought it worked better on the GamePad than with the Wii Remote the previous game used.

The mode that best suits the Wii U hardware is the one with the least new design in it.

That's both a strength and a limit. Virus Buster shows what the GamePad does well, but anyone who played Dr. Mario Online Rx has already met it.

Multiplayer holds up better than the solo grind

Multiplayer is local or online. Each player clears their own bottle, and big clears or chain reactions drop extra capsules onto the opponent's side. You win a game by clearing your viruses first or by filling your opponent's bottle, and the first player to win three games takes the match.

Critics described the online side as working but thin. Kemps said it was short on content and awkward to get around in, though it did function. Lee Meyer of Nintendo Life was more positive, praising the handicaps that even out uneven matches and lag he called "non-existent," with little waiting between rounds.

The bigger complaint is the formula itself. Schilling argued that Dr. Mario hasn't kept up with modern puzzle games and found every mode except multiplayer too repetitive to keep playing for long. He also thought the price was high, partly because Dr. Mario Online Rx had been free. USgamer's Jeremy Parrish agreed in part, but he credited the range of modes with giving Dr. Luigi more replay value than earlier entries. Meyer and Kuchera both saw little change but still found it a pleasing puzzle game. Kuchera called it satisfying and customizable, though "a little too safe."

That customization is real. You can change how fast the capsules fall and turn on a marker that shows where each one will land, which makes the game easier to start and easier to push yourself in.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet