Analysis · Driveclub

Driveclub split critics on its handling and shone brightest online

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The handling is where critics split hardest

Critics argued most about how Driveclub's cars feel to drive. At GamesRadar, Justin Towell gave it an 8/10. He praised the accessible handling and said the game had enough faith in it to drop driving assists entirely. Dale North at Destructoid called the controls responsive and satisfying.

Others heard the same handling as a flaw. Jeff Gerstmann at Giant Bomb gave the game a 2/5 and called the cars "weirdly grippy," with the whole package feeling like "a weird throwback" to older console racers. John Robertson at Computer and Video Games liked the game overall (8/10) but said the arcade handling "sits at odds" with the serious, clean-racing events. Luke Reilly at IGN found the handling easy to pick up but drifting much harder by comparison.

So the scores spread wide. A GamesRadar 8 sits next to a GameSpot 5/10 and a Giant Bomb 2/5, and the critic average worked out from the critic aggregates lands at 6.5 out of 10.

If you want a racer that's simple to pick up and quick to reward, Driveclub's handling is a plus. If you want cars that slide and fight back, critics suggest you'll find it too sticky.

Solo racing drew the most consistent complaints

Critics disagreed about the handling, but they mostly agreed on the AI. Destructoid, Joystiq, IGN and Giant Bomb all called out computer drivers that ram the player again and again. Ludwig Kietzmann at Joystiq said those repeated attacks ruin the single-player game, and he also faulted the lack of difficulty options.

The rest of the solo package took hits too:

  • Destructoid saw little replay value and found visual bugs in the in-car views.
  • Computer and Video Games wanted more variety in race types and challenges.
  • Giant Bomb found the menus confusing.
  • GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd called the settings "as lifeless as postcards" and disliked the soundtrack and overall presentation.

The single-player side comes down to Tour, a campaign of events with set cars and objectives, and Single Event, where you pick a drift, sprint, race or time trial and choose the location and weather. Critics didn't think either one held up well by itself.

Clubs and online play are the point

Driveclub is built around clubs of up to six players. Members take on challenges together and earn fame and XP. Fame sets both your own level and the club's, and leveling up gives you new cars, accolades and color schemes. Everything each member does counts toward the club's standing against other clubs.

This is where the low and high scores meet. Towell, the game's strongest early supporter, warned against playing it offline. He said he'd never seen a single-player mode so dull be "transformed so spectacularly" by being online. Computer and Video Games singled out the Clubs system for praise, and even Giant Bomb's harsh review liked the leaderboards.

That points to a clear dividing line. A player with friends to form a club, or one who enjoys chasing times on social leaderboards, gets the version of Driveclub that critics liked. A player who wants a long solo campaign gets the version they didn't.

What critics agreed on: how it looks and sounds

Nearly every review praised the presentation. Reilly at IGN called it "the best-looking racing game ever seen on a console." Even GameSpot and Giant Bomb, the two harshest reviews, praised the graphics and lighting. Destructoid and Joystiq both singled out the sound design.

The tracks are based on real regions such as Norway and Tamil Nadu in India. Rain, snow and a day-night cycle change the conditions. The game starts with 50 cars split into five classes, from hot hatches up to hypercars, and more than 60 others came later as free or paid downloads.

Later updates changed the verdict

The launch scores don't tell the whole story. Evolution Studios kept updating the game with free content for 18 months and added a Season Pass. GamesRadar re-reviewed it and raised its score to 4.5/5, calling the updates "arguably the finest collection" of post-release content in gaming. It singled out the photo mode and the new wet-weather and heat-haze effects.

The studio closed on March 22, 2016. The final update, on October 31, 2016, added 15 tracks and reversed versions from Driveclub VR. Eurogamer later called the game "the PS4 launch disaster that became a racing great," and VideoGamer called it one of the generation's finest games. That later praise softens some launch complaints, such as the lack of variety, but none of it says the AI drivers got any better.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet