Analysis · EA Sports UFC 2

EA Sports UFC 2 looks stunning, but critics split on how it fights

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed on the looks and split on the feel

The best and worst reviews on record praise the same game for different reasons. Game Informer's Brian Shea gave it an 8.5 and called it the "deliverance" of the promise the 2014 game made, pointing to the improved ground game and a deeper career mode. IGN's Josh Robertson gave it a 6.4 and said it "looks the part" but doesn't feel it. In his view every exchange was too robotic and rigid to capture the unpredictable side of a real UFC fight.

Neither of them disputed the presentation. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Jeff Landa scored it 7.0 and complained about the controls throughout, yet still said the game made something vicious look "outright stunning". GameSpot's Richard Wakeling called the visuals "incredible". Fighters show visible damage as a bout goes on, and the broadcast dressing is all there: referees, a crowd, an announcer, and commentary from Joe Rogan and Mike Goldberg. Shea's one complaint about that dressing was that the commentary repeats itself.

The critic aggregates average out to a critic average of 7.7. That number hides a real disagreement about the core fighting.

The ground game improved, and so did the learning curve

Grappling was the big fix. GameSpot, Game Informer and GamesRadar all singled out the ground game, and the developers improved submissions, parrying and blocking over the first game. A new on-screen guide called Grapple Assist shows players their options mid-scramble.

That guide matters, because the controls were the most common complaint. Landa called them "unintuitive". Polygon's Owen S. Good gave the game an 8 but found the controls uncomfortable at times and the submission system hard. Wakeling criticized the lack of proper tutorials, and Game Revolution's Devin Charles warned of a steep learning curve. The practice mode offers drills and an idle opponent, but critics didn't treat that as a substitute for teaching.

The AI adjusts when a player changes strategy mid-fight, which Good counted toward a well-judged difficulty balance. Robertson's complaint points the other way: he found no gaps to exploit, the "spaces between the lines" that decide real fights.

Career mode is the weakest part

Critics agreed on almost nothing else, but most of them disliked the career mode. Landa called it "bland". Good said it was too basic and lacked personality. GamesRadar's David Meikleham and Wakeling both counted it against the game. Hardcore Gamer's Adam Beck called it the most lackluster campaign in the package.

The mode lets players build a fighter or take a real one up through the UFC ranks, and it now includes female fighters. Shea was the outlier who found it deeper than before. Anyone buying mainly for a long solo campaign should go by the majority.

Knockout and Ultimate Team are where the fun lasts

The side modes earned warmer words. Knockout mode removes stamina bars and only counts wins by knockout, so it's all striking and no grappling. Shea called it "a blast" with a friend. The new Knockout Physics System decides finishes from the momentum and strength of the final hit, and Meikleham liked the knockdowns it produces.

Ultimate Team has players build a deck of fighter cards, earn coins and upgrade their fighters against other players' decks. Charles praised it and the game's long shelf life. Beck found the online Championship mode more rewarding than the career, even though it leans on card packs and random pulls.

Physics is still the weak spot. Landa found it unrealistic, Beck said it goes "out of whack" too often, and Meikleham's summary opened with "buggy".

The roster runs past 250 fighters, men and women. Charles also called the replay system "poor", which hurts in a game built around highlight-reel finishes. The game was nominated for Fighting Game of the Year at the 20th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet