Elden Ring's open world earned its acclaim, but its PC port and menus didn't
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics loved the exploration and faulted the Windows version
Elden Ring's strongest praise and its sharpest complaint have little to do with each other. GameSpot's Tamoor Hussain called the Lands Between the most expansive of FromSoftware's settings and named exploration and discovery as the game's main appeal. Reviewers also often reported framerate problems in the Windows version, and some faulted its menus and accessibility systems.
Neither one cancels the other out. Critics loved the open world itself, and their complaints were about things around it. Most of the weight sits with the praise. Metacritic reports "universal acclaim", OpenCritic found 98% of critics recommending it, and it collected over 300 Game of the Year awards. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 9.3 out of 10.
An open world that pays you back for every detour
The Lands Between has six main areas, from Limgrave's grassy plains and ancient ruins to Caelid, a wasteland full of undead monsters. A demigod rules each area and serves as one of its main bosses. Hidden catacombs, tunnels and caves lie in between, each with its own bosses and useful items.
IGN's Mitchell Saltzman credited the game with rewarding exploration in every part of the map, and The Guardian's Simon Parkin called its environments "intriguing and inventive". Many reviewers compared the exploration favorably with The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. Critics also liked the linear dungeons tucked into the open map, which keep the tighter design of earlier FromSoftware games alive inside a much bigger world.
Travel is part of why the size works. Reviewers called the mount, Torrent, and fast travel (available outside combat) large improvements to exploring. They also said the checkpoints, called Sites of Grace, were placed in ways that made the game easier to get into.
Hard by default, but you choose which fight to take
The game has no easy mode, and reviewers both praised and criticized that. Others called it the most accessible Souls game, because you can walk away from a threat you can't beat and come back with more experience. Critics said the combat gives you plenty of ways to fight while keeping the challenge intact. Here's what you have to work with:
- A starting class that sets your first spells, equipment and attributes
- Melee weapons, ranged weapons, shields, dodging and parries that open enemies to critical hits
- Spells cast with a staff or sacred seal, which can buff weapons, attack from range or heal
- Ashes of War, which add a special weapon art and can be swapped at Sites of Grace
- Stealth for slipping past enemies or landing critical hits from hiding
- Spirit Ashes for summoning friendly spirits, plus crafted poison darts and exploding pots
Death works the way it does in FromSoftware's earlier games. You drop all your runes where you fell, and if you die again before getting back to them, they're gone. Runes pay for levels, items and weapon upgrades, so losing them hurts. Stakes of Marika ease this a little by letting you respawn near some spots where you died.
If a boss keeps beating you, the game's own answer is to leave, explore and come back with more runes and better gear.
A cryptic story behind a famous name
Hidetaka Miyazaki directed the game, and the fantasy writer George R. R. Martin provided the worldbuilding. Reviewers noted that the story doesn't read like Martin's writing. Ars Technica's Kyle Orland called the storytelling "characteristically sparse and cryptic". Eurogamer's Aoife Wilson found Martin's heavy role in the marketing "baffling" when his part in the story was unclear.
Other critics were kinder. Destructoid's Chris Carter called the story "low key" but better told than in earlier FromSoftware games. Saltzman said the side stories, not any grand plot, kept him "enthralled".
Read this as a note about expectations, not a mark against the game. If you came for a story in George R. R. Martin's writing style, full of dialogue, you'll be let down. If you like piecing a world together from the odd characters you meet, you'll find plenty to work with.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Elden Ring en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q64826862 wikidata.org