Empire at War makes you win the fight before the shooting starts
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every battle is fought with what you brought
A fight starts when two forces meet, either fleets in orbit or troops landing on an enemy planet. From then on, you can only use the units you carried into that system. If you arrived with an X-wing squadron and no capital ships, that's your space battle. If you landed without an AT-AT, you won't get one halfway through.
Each side can only have so many units on the field at once. The rest wait as reinforcements, and you can call them in to set drop zones when the battle allows it. On the ground, capturing Reinforcement Points raises that cap, so the map gives you something to fight over besides the enemy army. Defenders get an extra edge: any buildings they've put up on the surface, or the space station they've built above it, join the fight.
Space battles use starfighter squadrons and large ships. Ground battles use infantry and vehicles. The game makes you get good at both, because every planet has to be taken in orbit and then on the surface.
Critics loved the space fights and found the ground war repetitive
Reviewers mostly agreed on where the game shines. The Detroit Free Press called the big space battles "a real thrill to behold" but said the ground conflicts that fill most of the game were "not particularly inspiring." IGN praised the game's style and warned that its few new ideas couldn't make up for repetitive fights if you care more about strategy than about Star Wars.
The Sydney Morning Herald made the same point more bluntly. It said the game hits the right notes for fans, but players should expect to "grind out" their wins. Because so many battles are planet-by-planet sieges with the same two factions, a long campaign repeats a lot of the same combat.
The galaxy map is where the real strategy happens
Galactic Conquest is the sandbox mode, and it ties the battles together. You play the Rebel Alliance or the Empire on a three-dimensional galaxy map. A weaker Pirate faction stays out of the fight unless someone attacks it. Depending on the scenario, you win by killing the enemy leader (Mon Mothma or Emperor Palpatine), by protecting or destroying the Death Star, or by wiping the other side off the map.
Planets and mining facilities earn you credits. You spend them on research, defenses, vehicles and troops. Planets also give you bonuses, and some only help one faction. Holding Kuat, for example, makes Imperial Star Destroyers 25 percent cheaper. Choosing which worlds to take shapes the army you'll field.
- Campaign: a semi-open, mostly linear story for each side, building toward the Battle of Yavin. The map opens up as you finish missions, such as stealing X-wing prototypes. The Rebels get most of their technology through the Droid Duo, while the Empire unlocks it by completing missions.
- Skirmish: standard real-time strategy matches on land or in space. You build a base or upgrade a space station, buy units and move up technology levels. It takes the least time of the three modes.
Why it was well liked anyway
GameSpot said it "delivers a true Star Wars experience." The A.V. Club gave it a B and admitted you could find a deeper or better-tuned strategy game, "but this one has AT-ATs." That sums up much of the praise: it's a good strategy game made more appealing by a setting it handles well.
Not everyone thought the ideas were thin. The editors of Computer Games Magazine named it the tenth-best computer game of 2006 and called it "one of the most inventive games in years." The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Strategy Game of the Year.
For long-term value, Galactic Conquest is the mode to come back to, because each scenario changes what you're fighting for. The expansion, Forces of Corruption, followed in October 2006. You'll still be fighting a lot of similar ground battles, so how much you enjoy the space war and the galaxy map will decide how long the game holds you.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Star Wars: Empire at War en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q55315 wikidata.org