Analysis · Epic Mickey

Epic Mickey brings Oswald home, but its camera trips the paintbrush idea

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The series starts with a rabbit Disney lost and won back

Epic Mickey is where the series begins. Junction Point Studios made it for the Wii in 2010, and Epic Mickey 2: The Power of Two followed in 2012. Its pitch is Disney's own back catalog. Mickey accidentally damages a world that Yen Sid built for forgotten characters and concepts, and he has to put it right.

The big name in that world is Oswald the Lucky Rabbit, created by Walt Disney and Ub Iwerks and originally owned by Universal Pictures. The Walt Disney Company got the character back in 2006, and this game is the first time Mickey and Oswald appear together. Critics noticed the care. GameZone's Shirley Chase praised its use of Disney history. GamesRadar's Chris Antista, who called himself a "diehard Disney dork", described it as a "thoroughly heartwarming salute to Disney".

The paintbrush changes how a platformer solves problems

The new idea is Mickey's magic paintbrush. Paint draws things into the world and thinner erases them. You can thin an obstacle out of existence and paint it back later. You can paint an enemy to win it over or thin it to destroy it. Beetleworx enemies mostly ignore both fluids, so they have to be fought directly.

Both fluids come from limited reserves that refill slowly, so every stroke has a cost. Spending thinner freely now can make a later task harder. Power-ups in some areas refill the tanks quickly. Mickey can also bring objects to life from sketches: a watch slows time and a television distracts enemies.

Choices matter beyond a single room. A morality system, in the same family as Infamous and Shadow the Hedgehog, changes which alliances, side-quests and power-ups open up. With the right actions you can skip some mini-bosses entirely. E-tickets, the in-game currency, play a part in boss fights and also buy quest items, refills, pins and concept art.

What it kept from the old cartoons

Between the areas of the Wasteland, the game drops into 2D side-scrolling stages based on Mickey's cartoon shorts, such as Steamboat Willie and Clock Cleaners. Others reach further back or sideways:

  • three are based on Oswald shorts, including Trolley Troubles and Oh What a Knight
  • two draw on Sleeping Beauty and Fantasia

These stages are the clearest link to classic Disney, and they hold the game's history lesson together. Collectible pins, mostly bronze, silver and gold with a few special ones, give completionists another reason to explore.

Critics kept blaming the camera

Metacritic lists the game at "mixed or average reviews", and the critic aggregate is 69/100 from nine reviews. The critic average, calculated from those critic numbers, is 6.9 out of 10.

The highest scores still came with complaints. IGN gave it 8/10 for its charm, story and art design while faulting the camera, the controls and the lack of voice acting. Good Game's two presenters scored it 6 and 7. They compared the brush to the water jet pack in Super Mario Sunshine, said the game falls well short of that one, and disliked that levels reset when you leave. They also found it less "dark" than the hype suggested: a kids' game, but a clever one.

GameZone named the camera as the main source of "cheap deaths". Giant Bomb was harshest at 2 out of 5 stars, calling it a platformer "about a generation behind" with flashes of inspiration that mostly highlight what it could have been. On the other side, G4TV named it Best Wii Game, and GamesRadar's Antista said no third-person platformer had won him over like this since the original Banjo-Kazooie.

The pattern is consistent. Critics liked what the game is about and how it looks. Their scores depended on how much the camera and controls bothered them.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet