Analysis · Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold: The Fafnir Knight

Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold makes you draw every map, and critics barely argued

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The biggest split between critics is four points

Critics didn't really disagree about this game. The widest gap in its scores is between two aggregate figures from March 27, 2016: 83/100 from 39 reviews, and 79%. That's a spread of four points, and reception was positive across the board.

Japan was even more uniform. Famitsu scored it four nines, for 36 out of 40. When every score on a panel lands on the same number, it usually means the reviewers agreed on what the game is trying to do and how well it does it.

A narrow spread like this changes the question. Critics weren't torn over whether it's good. What's left is whether you want the kind of game it is, and that depends on a few design choices it won't bend on.

Both modes hand you a blank map

There are two ways to play, and they differ more than most remakes' extra modes do.

  • Classic mode works like the rest of the series. You build your own party of custom characters and draw your own maps.
  • Story mode first appeared in Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl. It gives you a fixed cast of characters, cutscenes, voice acting and a larger story.

Here's what doesn't change: in both modes, you draw the dungeon maps yourself. Story mode adds a plot around the exploring, but it doesn't take the mapping off your hands. That's the line that will decide whether you like it. If filling in a map floor by floor sounds satisfying, both modes give you plenty of it. If you wanted Story mode to turn this into a more typical role-playing game, it won't.

Picking a mode also means picking what you care about more. Classic lets you build the party you want. Story trades that freedom for preset characters with voices and a story to follow.

Picnic is the real entry point

There are three difficulty settings, and the lowest is the one that matters most to new players:

  1. Picnic keeps things easy.
  2. Normal is moderately hard but manageable.
  3. Expert is as tough as the game gets.

Together with Story mode, Picnic lets someone who has never played a dungeon crawler try one on easy terms. Expert is there for veterans who'd find Normal too gentle. The game isn't narrowing its audience here. It's giving each kind of player a setting to start on.

The difficulty and the mode are both your choice. Drawing the map is not.

A second chance at Heroes of Lagaard

This is a remake of Etrian Odyssey II: Heroes of Lagaard, developed and published by Atlus for the Nintendo 3DS. It came out in Japan in November 2014, in North America in August 2015, and in the PAL region in February 2016. It sold 59,531 copies in its first week in Japan. It's rated Teen.

For anyone who never played the original, this is the version to get, with both modes and three difficulty levels in one package. Players who already finished Heroes of Lagaard are a harder call. Story mode and the voiced cast are the main reasons to go back, so how much you care about a story should decide it.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet