Ever Oasis makes its desert town worth running between dungeon fights
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The oasis and the desert are meant to feed each other
Ever Oasis rests on one idea: a town you manage and a desert you explore should keep each other running. You play a young Seedling, Tethu or Tethi, whom a water spirit named Esna asks to build the last oasis left in a desert threatened by a corruption called Chaos. Grezzo designed the two halves to form a cycle, and nearly every judgment critics made comes back to how well that cycle holds.
Most reviewers thought it held. IGN's Brendan Graeber, Nintendo Life's Morgan Sleeper and Destructoid's CJ Andriessen all praised the way the two modes connect. Sleeper called the result "fresh and undeniably new", and Andriessen said the halves complemented each other. Where critics found fault, it was usually in a part of the game that sits outside the loop or slows it down.
Running the town is the part critics loved
The oasis grows as you recruit travelers from the desert's tribes. Some residents open Bloom Booths, small shops along the main street that sell potions, juices, weapons, robes and turbans. You keep the booths stocked with materials gathered in the field and take a share of the profits in Dewadems, the game's currency. Restock a booth consistently and finish its owner's quests, and it ranks up.
This is where the core idea pays off most clearly. Upkeep that would be busywork in another game becomes the reason to go exploring, and what you bring back shows up right away on the main street. Graeber felt even the routine maintenance felt worthwhile rather than like chores, and wrote that the game made him care about his town as much as about saving the world. GameSpot's Matt Espineli also enjoyed watching the oasis grow step by step.
Polygon's Allegra Frank disagreed and found the town-building too shallow. That was the harshest view on record, and it's worth keeping in mind if you've spent a lot of time with deeper management games.
Combat is where the loop strains
The desert half is a real-time dungeon crawler. You lock on, mix weak and strong attacks, dodge and cast elemental magic, with up to three party members recruited from the oasis. Each tribe has its own weapon: the Darkus use spears, the Serkah hammers and the Lagora dual blades. Enemies are strong or weak against each type, so the people you recruit at home decide how you fight away from it.
That link is a good one on paper. The weak spot is that an AI controls whichever party members you aren't playing. Espineli said fights were often bogged down by unreliable companions, and inconsistent AI was one of the complaints reviewers raised most. You can switch characters at any time, which helps, but it means stepping in to cover for your party.
- Difficulty: Frank found the game too easy.
- Pacing: critics often named the slow beginning as a weakness, and the loop takes a while to get going.
- Dungeons: Andriessen praised dungeon design inspired by The Legend of Zelda.
Familiar pieces in an unusual arrangement
The game was directed and produced by Koichi Ishii, known for the Final Fantasy and Mana series, and critics could see those influences. Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard called it "a collection of familiar ideas" assembled in a new way, but said no single part stood out. USgamer's Kat Bailey praised its polish and charm and said it could have been among the best 3DS games if it had "aimed higher".
The story didn't help. Reviewers repeatedly called it underdeveloped, so the loop has to carry the game without much help from the narrative.
Critics broadly liked the presentation. Sleeper pointed to an orchestral score with Middle Eastern influences, and Vice praised how the music changes tone from day to night.
That warmth may explain why the game left a mark on some critics despite a weak launch. It opened in 28th place on the sales chart and had sold 15,907 copies as of July 16, 2017. Nintendo Life's Tony Stephenson named it his most memorable game of 2017 and called it a "truly stunning game" that went unappreciated.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Ever Oasis en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24807252 wikidata.org