EverQuest earned its legend through cooperation, not its combat
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Praised as a landmark and faulted for its first hours
The strongest praise is hard to top. Dan Amrich of GamePro wrote that the bar for online gaming had been "obliterated" and called EverQuest the first true online killer app. GameSpot named it its 1999 Game of the Year and said its own editors spent weeks exploring Norrath when they should have been working.
The sharpest criticism also came from GameSpot. Greg Kasavin found the combat "uninteresting", the manual "horrible" and the quest system "half-baked", and he noted some bugs. He still called it one of the most memorable games he had played.
Critics kept doing that: they listed the flaws and recommended the game anyway. Its Metacritic score was 85 out of 100.
A world built for groups more than solo players
You create a character from one of twelve races at launch, ranging from humans and high elves to ogres and trolls. Later expansions added lizard-people, cat-people, frog-people and dragon-people. You also choose a class, such as a wizard, ranger or cleric, plus a patron deity and a starting city. Then you head into Norrath, a medieval fantasy world of over five hundred zones, where you fight monsters for loot and experience, take quests from non-player characters and learn trade skills if you want to.
The design pushes players to team up, with each person filling a role in the group. Critics treated this as the game's real strength:
- Kasavin pointed out that, unlike earlier online games, EverQuest let you play on servers where other players couldn't attack you unless you agreed.
- Player-versus-player fights are limited to a PvP server, arena zones and agreed duels.
- Baldric of Game Revolution found it more cooperative than Ultima Online. He also found less to do with the world itself, calling the game "player oriented" rather than world oriented.
That last point is the trade-off. EverQuest's appeal comes from the people you play with more than from the world you play in.
The early levels are the hardest sell
Critics criticized the opening hours more than anything else. Amrich found the early levels repetitive and the documentation so thin that he told new players to look for help on fan sites. Edge ranked it the best online role-playing game yet and also warned that it would be very unforgiving to newcomers at the start.
The combat didn't help. Kasavin called it a little "boring". Computer Games Magazine saw the same simplicity as a good thing. The reviews disagree about whether simple combat is a flaw or just leaves room for the group play to stand out.
Technically ahead of the pack in 1999
The launch had server problems, but reviewers said the game ran well even on modest network hardware. Tal Blevins of IGN said it rarely had major lag. He called the visuals "excellent" and the spell, lighting and particle effects "particularly impressive". His complaint was customization: apart from face types, characters of the same race looked mostly alike.
GameSpot UK called it "a technological tour de force". The awards that followed were about engineering as much as fun. Sony Online Entertainment received a Technology & Engineering Emmy Award in 2007. In 2011 the Game Developers Choice Online Awards gave EverQuest a Hall of Fame award, crediting it as the first MMORPG with a guild system and raiding.
What the 1999 reviews don't cover
Every review here describes the game at launch. Daybreak Game Company still develops and publishes EverQuest, and the races added in expansions show that it has kept growing since. The complaints about onboarding and the manual were about the 1999 version.
The audience is much smaller than it was. Subscriptions peaked at 550,000 by the end of 2004. As of September 2020, the game had 66,000 subscribers and 82,000 monthly active players. That is far below the peak, but it is still a sizable group to play with in a game built around grouping.
Sources
- Wikipedia: EverQuest en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1134845 wikidata.org