Analysis · Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Expedition 33 pairs acclaimed parry combat with a world critics found flat

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Beautiful to look at, less interesting to walk through

Edge called the art direction “dreamily intoxicating.” GameSpot's Richard Wakeling agreed about the looks, then called the same world “mechanically uninteresting” to explore. That split sums up how critics saw Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. Almost everyone praised the story, the music and the fights. The criticism landed on the places in between.

The praise still outweighs the criticism by a wide margin. Critic aggregates put the game at 91/100 across 61 reviews on each of its three platforms and 92/100 across 200 reviews, and OpenCritic reported that 98% of critics recommended it. Famitsu's four critics each gave it 9 out of 10. The critic average of 9.2 is calculated from those critic numbers.

Critics also pointed out that the game has no mini-map, which can leave players lost at times. It's a small complaint, but it fits the larger one: the parts of the game spent walking around got less care than the parts spent fighting.

Turn-based fights that still test your reflexes

On paper, this is a turn-based role-playing game. You choose an item, a melee attack that builds Ability Points, or a ranged attack or Skill that spends them. Ranged attacks are aimed freely, like in a third-person shooter, and Skills come with a quick time event that makes them stronger if you hit it.

The enemy's turn is where it differs from older turn-based games. You can dodge, parry or jump over attacks in real time. Parrying needs tighter timing than dodging, but it gives you Ability Points and a counterattack. The Guardian's Malindy Hetfeld wrote that a good counter felt “deeply satisfying every time,” and PCGamesN's Josh Brown called the system a “hyper-stimulating” take on an old genre.

Eurogamer's Ed Nightingale praised how each character brings “a new system to learn.” The six playable characters show how far apart those systems are:

  • Lune builds elemental Stains that power up her Skills.
  • Maelle switches Stances that change her damage and defense.
  • Sciel stacks Foretell on enemies with magical cards, then cashes it in.
  • Gustave builds charges from attacks and releases them for bigger hits.
  • Verso climbs Perfection ranks by landing hits and avoiding damage.
  • Monoco transforms into enemies and uses their abilities.

On top of that sit 210 Pictos (three can be equipped per character) and five core stats to spend points on with each level. There's a lot to tinker with if you like building a party.

If the parry timing works for you, most of the game's flaws stop mattering. If timed inputs frustrate you, this game asks for them constantly.

A story about losing time, with music to match

The premise is grim. Every year, the Paintress causes the Gommage, which erases everyone at or above an age that keeps getting lower. Expedition 33 sets out to destroy her. IGN's Michael Higham praised how the game handles “mortality, grief, and the small moments of joy.” Push Square's Liam Croft said every cutscene stays gripping, helped by “excellent voice acting.”

Back at camp, conversations raise relationship levels with the rest of the party. Those relationships open up new cutscenes, skills and quests, so the story and the combat feed into each other.

The soundtrack drew some of the warmest praise. Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard pointed to the contrast between the “somber piano music” behind the quiet scenes and combat themes that lift the energy at the right moment.

Where critics pushed back

Edge raised the most useful warning for anyone planning a long playthrough: finishing side quests can leave your party overleveled, which makes later boss fights much less challenging and less rewarding. If you care about tough bosses, pace the optional content rather than clearing all of it before moving on. Edge still called the game a “masterpiece.”

Wakeling listed weak exploration and small quality-of-life problems, then concluded that these missteps don't “significantly detract” from the game. Across the reviews, the complaints were about rough edges, not about the core of the game.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet