Analysis · Far Cry 3

Far Cry 3's island outshines the story that brings you there

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A world critics adored and a main quest some called clumsy

IGN's Mitch Dyer credited Far Cry 3 with an "astonishing sense of place," and GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd argued that the game is more about its world than its story. PC Gamer's Tom Francis made the harshest point: he described the linear main quest as a "guided tour" of the clumsiest ways to force a story and a video game together.

Both views hold up, but the praise clearly won. Critic aggregates sit between 88 and 91 out of 100 across Windows, PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360. The game works best as an island to roam freely, with a plot you pick up when you feel like it.

Rook Islands is the reason to go

The setting is a tropical archipelago in the Pacific controlled by pirates and mercenaries, and you can explore all of it. You get around in dune buggies, all-terrain vehicles, cargo trucks, jet skis, boats and hang gliders, and a wingsuit turns up later.

Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell said the island was the main reason the game won him over. He pointed to how much there is to do, the island's history and the wild animals, whose behavior keeps play unpredictable. Leopards, sharks and other wildlife interact with each other like a real ecosystem. VanOrd said this made the world more believable.

The map has a clear structure. Climbing a radio tower and removing its scrambler reveals part of the map and its points of interest. Retaking a pirate outpost turns it into a rebel base with fast travel, vendors and new side missions. Hunting supplies the skins for crafting weapon holsters and ammo pouches, and gathered plants become healing syringes.

Polygon's Arthur Gies said the game's systems flow into each other and produce events nobody scripted. GamesRadar's Ryan Taljonick added that this gives each player their own stories.

Stealth gives the combat its best moments

Any mission can be played loud or quiet. You can tag guards with a camera, throw rocks to distract them, and use silenced weapons or a knife so nobody raises the alarm and calls in reinforcements. VanOrd called stealth "a blast", and Bramwell named it one of the game's strengths.

Take an outpost without setting off its alarm, and the fight never grows bigger than the one you chose.

Three skill trees shape how Jason fights:

  • Spider: stealth takedowns and hunting
  • Heron: long-range takedowns and mobility
  • Shark: assault takedowns and health

VanOrd credited these role-playing elements with giving the game a real sense of progress. The complaints are specific. Destructoid's James Stephanie Sterling said many side objectives got repetitive fast and found travel annoying. VanOrd and Francis were frustrated by respawning enemies. Game Informer's Matt Bertz wished the human enemies adapted more. Gies warned that the sheer amount of content could be "intimidating".

Vaas carries a story that stumbles elsewhere

Jason Brody's vacation goes wrong when pirates kidnap his friends, and he has to rescue them and escape the island. Sterling called the story "tightly written", and Bertz called it "compelling". Dyer found Jason relatable because of his many flaws. Critics singled out Mando's performance as the villain Vaas, and Taljonick said Vaas made some missions memorable.

The criticism runs deep. VanOrd questioned the heavy focus on drug use. Critics also disliked how fast Jason becomes a capable fighter and how Vaas's death is handled. 1Up.com's Bob Mackey said the game lacked the cultural commentary it promised, and Gies called the story clichéd. Some critics objected to how the game handles misogyny and homophobia and to its use of the white savior trope.

Play it for Vaas and the island, not for Jason's arc.

The multiplayer is the part to skip

A four-player co-op mode is set six months before the main story. Bertz called it "a fun diversion", and Francis called it fun too, though he missed having a server browser. VanOrd said co-op didn't use the open world the team had built. Dyer was the harshest: he called the modes uninspired, criticized the confusing maps and the lack of difficulty scaling, and said co-op turned the game into a "mindless shooter".

Sterling said the competitive mode lacked new ideas. Bramwell called multiplayer the least interesting part of the game but still counted the bonus content as part of a generous package. That's the fair way to see it: it's extra, and not the reason to buy.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet