Analysis · Far Cry 5

Far Cry 5 builds a great Montana sandbox around a story critics shrugged at

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Closer fights and bullets that drop

Far Cry 5 is a first-person shooter that lets you cross Hope County, a fictional corner of Montana, on foot or by vehicle, fighting cult soldiers and dangerous wildlife along the way. The basic loop matches earlier Far Cry games, with two changes that affect almost every fight.

  • More melee. The game puts new weight on close-quarters combat and gives you a wider range of melee weapons than earlier entries did, alongside the usual ranged and explosive arsenal.
  • Bullet drop. A new ballistics system makes bullets fall over distance, so long shots ask more of you than pointing at a head.

IGN's Daemon Hatfield, who scored it 8.9 out of 10, called it a "wide-open playground" stocked with enemies, allies, "temperamental wildlife" and explosions. Even Polygon, which was harder on the game, said the world behind the plot holds what the series "does best."

A map that opens early and pushes back as you win

The biggest structural change is how little the game steers you. After the introductory missions, most of the county is open, and you're set loose with little context and few objective markers. Earlier Far Cry games unlocked their maps step by step through story missions. Here you pick the order.

Creative director Dan Hay described the design as taking the series' enemy outposts, small areas with several ways to attack, and stretching that idea across the whole map. His stated goal was an "anecdote factory": two players head off in opposite directions from the same spot and come back with completely different stories.

Progress runs on Resistance Points, earned by doing things in a region. They build toward major story events and fill a Resistance Meter with three tiers per region. The enemy mix grows as the meter rises, from basic soldiers at first to aerial patrols and airborne assaults by the end. In effect, the county gets tougher because you're winning.

You don't have to fight alone. A recruitment system lets you bring locals along as Guns for Hire, and a set of Specialists adds companions with their own skills and personalities. It replaces the beacon system from earlier games.

Where the story lost critics

You play an unnamed junior deputy sheriff, trapped in Hope County and working with resistance groups against Joseph Seed and his doomsday cult, the Project at Eden's Gate. The deputy is customizable and fully silent, with no voiced lines and no set personality. That helps you put yourself in the role, but it also raised doubts about how much the story could carry.

Polygon's review, which gave the game 6.5 out of 10, blamed "a weak story with bland characters" for holding up a strong open world. The endings hurt the story most. Critics argued that both outcomes made the player's earlier actions meaningless, and the endings split critical opinion more than anything else in the game.

The setting drew attention well before release. Its themes of religious extremism and far-right movements inside the United States led journalists to expect controversy. After launch, though, several outlets attacked it from the other side, for avoiding its own subject:

Polygon's Ben Kuchera called it a "defiantly inoffensive mess," and The Verge's Andrew Webster wrote that it creates the illusion of having something to say, then refuses to say it.

Writing for The A.V. Club, William Hughes made a similar point about the villains, calling them an "easily digestible evil." If you want a shooter with a sharp point of view, critics largely agreed this isn't one.

Why it lasts past the credits

Far Cry 5 gives you more to do than the campaign. Besides side quests and a branching storyline borrowed from role-playing games, it includes a co-operative multiplayer mode, a competitive multiplayer mode and a map editor. With co-op, the anecdote-factory idea works best: the open county and its pile of systems make more sense with a second player making a mess beside you.

Critic aggregates sit in a narrow band, between 80 and 83 out of 100 across platforms, which works out to a critic average of 8.2. That consistency fits the reviews themselves. Few critics disliked playing it, and most of the disagreement was about what it had to say.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet