Analysis · Fighter Within

Fighter Within asks you to punch thin air, and Kinect rarely notices

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Swinging at nothing until a combo fires

Fighter Within has no controller. You stand in front of the Kinect camera and throw punches, and the game is supposed to turn your movements into your fighter's attacks. Critics said that's where it breaks down.

IGN found the camera reliably picked up only basic punches. Everything beyond that came through unpredictably, which IGN said left fights feeling "disjointed" and turned the whole thing into a "haphazard mess." If a fighting game can't read your inputs, nothing you plan matters.

GameSpot described the core loop bluntly, and the steps are worth setting out because reviewers kept describing the same pattern:

  1. Stand still in front of the TV through a long loading screen.
  2. Punch at thin air as fast as you can until a combo triggers.
  3. Watch a lifeless combo animation play out.
  4. Repeat until the opponent goes down.

That loop puts flailing ahead of timing, reading your opponent and spacing, which are the skills fighting games usually reward. When mashing is the most reliable way to get a combo, fights stop rewarding skill.

The same Kinect problems on a new console

Fighter Within came out on November 22, 2013 as an exclusive launch title for the Xbox One. It's a sequel to Fighters Uncaged (2010) and was developed by the Belgian studio Daoka. A new console and a new camera should have been the fresh start the idea needed. Several reviewers said it wasn't, and that the problems were just as common as on the Kinect for Xbox 360.

GameZone's Mike Splechta saw it as part of a wider problem with games that only work with Kinect:

"Fighter Within really showcases the larger problem with Kinect only games: they just don't work."

Metro was the only outlet to hold back a little. It gave the game 2 out of 10 and called it a very poor start for Kinect games on the new console, but still saw "some small cause for optimism" under the bland fighting. That's the kindest view of the game on record, and it's about Kinect's future, not this game.

A story and roster that don't help

The single-player structure doesn't give the fights much reason to exist. IGN called the storyline "laughably bad" and a "flimsy excuse" for fighting a long line of AI opponents, and said those opponents look as dumb as they fight. So the AI isn't a test of skill, and the plot isn't a reason to keep going.

The presentation drew criticism too. GameSpot singled out the "excruciatingly long" loading times. In a motion game that's worse than usual: you're standing and waiting, ready to move, with nothing to do.

Game Informer summed up the game in four words: "Fighter Within is garbage."

Why it ended up as a launch-day warning

Fighter Within is mostly remembered for how badly it was received. Metacritic listed its reviews as "generally unfavorable," and the aggregates back that up: 24 out of 100 from seven Xbox One reviews, and 25 out of 100 from 26 reviews as of February 20, 2014. The critic average, worked out from those critic numbers, is 2.5 out of 10.

The single-digit scores were just as harsh. Digital Spy gave it one star out of five and said it might have passed as a tech demo but wasn't worth the time or money as a full-priced next-generation release. The Digital Fix gave it 1 out of 10 and argued that being a launch title made it worse, because it fed off the goodwill of early adopters. Its advice was "avoid, avoid, avoid."

The game has no other modes or long-term hooks to make up for a failing core, so it doesn't last. It's rated Teen, it's single-player only, and it only runs on Xbox One with a Kinect. If you want a fighting game you can stick with, almost anything built for a controller is a better bet.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet