Analysis · Final Fantasy VII

Final Fantasy VII bets everything on story, and critics say the bet paid off

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built to play like a movie you steer

Critics kept coming back to one idea: Final Fantasy VII tries to fuse a melodramatic story, its play and its presentation so that none of them feels bolted on. GameSpot wrote that technology, playability and narrative had "never before" combined as well. Edge went further and said it came close to being an interactive movie in playable form.

When it came out, that idea landed hard. The game drew perfect scores from 1Up.com, AllGame, Computer and Video Games, GameFan, GamePro and Next Generation, among others. GameFan called it "quite possibly the greatest game ever made".

The aggregates tell a slightly cooler story over time. One aggregate of 20 reviews sits at 92/100, while two later counts of 25 and 26 reviews, dated 2019 and 2021, settle at 81. The critic average of 8.7, computed from those critic aggregates, sits between them. It's still high, but the first critics were more dazzled than later ones.

The story is where the idea holds best

Cloud Strife is a mercenary who joins an eco-terrorist group trying to stop a megacorporation from draining the planet's life essence for energy. That fight turns into a pursuit of Sephiroth, a superhuman who wants to wound the planet and be reborn as a god. Along the way Cloud bonds with his party, including Aerith Gainsborough, who holds the secret to saving their world.

This is the part that best fits the movie idea. EGM's four reviewers each gave it 9.5 out of 10 and singled out the story line above everything else. GamePro called the storytelling "dramatic, sentimental, and touching" and credited small body movements with bringing the characters to life. Computer and Video Games praised its well-developed characters.

The praise came with two caveats. Next Generation said the story takes a while to get going, and EGM was disappointed that the ending left loose ends unresolved.

Battles that keep up with the drama

A story-first game can let its fights go slack. Critics said this one doesn't. Fights start at random on the world map and in towns and dungeons, plus at set story moments. They use the Active Time Battle system: each character has a gauge, and when it fills you choose a command. Both GamePro and the Official U.S. PlayStation Magazine said this gives fights a tension and urgency rare in the genre.

  • Materia, orbs you equip from the menu, decide which spells and commands each character can use, so building a party is mostly about how you spread them around.
  • Limit Breaks are powerful character-specific moves that charge as a character takes hits.
  • Summons call in monsters, and OPM called their animations "absolutely awe-inspiring".

IGN's Jay Boor called the battle system the game's strongest point. His one complaint was that you can only bring three characters into a fight at once, which he called "the game's only shortcoming".

Where the seams show

The words are the weakest part of a game built on its story. OPM found the translation "a bit muddy", and GamePro called it a significant weakness. RPGamer was harsher, saying typos and errors made an already confusing plot harder to follow. Critics didn't fully agree here: EGM thought the North American script was a big improvement on the Japanese original.

The other knock is structure. OPM and GameSpot both questioned how linear the game is. Vehicles and chocobos gradually open up more of the world map, but the story decides when.

PC Gamer's verdict on the 1998 Windows release: Square did "only what was required" to get it running, yet the game was "still a winner on the PC".

Those PC reviews also flagged crashes across different computers, weaker music through PC sound cards and pre-rendered backgrounds that looked worse than on PlayStation. They did praise the sharper battle scenes. These complaints are about the original Windows release, not the later versions on PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, Xbox One and mobile.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet