Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade wins on combat and loses time to filler
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics split over the padding, not the fighting
Critics barely argued about the combat. Their real disagreement was over how the game fills its hours between the big story beats. Final Fantasy VII Remake covers only the opening section of the 1997 original, set in the city of Midgar, and it stretches that section into a full-length game.
Some outlets felt the stretch showed. IGN praised a story with "real emotional arcs" but criticized the "filler" and some convoluted new plot points and side missions. RPGamer said the game leaned on "padding" to expand areas it considered linear for the genre. EGM pointed to a sequence in the Shinra headquarters where you keep switching characters just to open doors. GamesRadar called some side quests lackluster, though it liked the character interactions inside them.
Others read the same expansion as the main attraction. GameSpot's Tamoor Hussain found it rich in details the original never explored and called it a smaller, more personal take on the story. Eurogamer went further and rated it above the original game.
The slow parts are where the cast gets its room
The extra material is doing a job. The added hours are where minor AVALANCHE members get scenes of their own, and critics praised the game for exactly that. They also singled out how it handles Midgar itself. Cody Christian's performance as Cloud drew particular praise, as did his scenes with the wider cast. Destructoid enjoyed the cast too, Aerith most of all.
So the disagreement comes down to what you want from a remake:
- If you want to spend time in Midgar and get to know characters who were sketches in 1997, the slower stretches are part of the appeal.
- If you want the story to keep moving, the door puzzles and errand quests will feel like detours.
Easy Allies said its reviewers finished in 38 hours and still had plenty of quests left. That's a lot of game for one city, and how you feel about it decides most of how you'll feel about the game.
Rule of thumb: if the original's Midgar was your favorite part, the padding works in the remake's favor. If you only liked the original for where its story went next, it works against it.
Combat is the part nobody needs to forgive
Fights happen in real time, but the Active Time Battle gauge from the original survives in a new form. It fills slowly on its own and faster when you land attacks. Once a segment is full, you can pause the action to cast magic, use items or trigger special moves. You can also map those abilities to shortcut buttons and never stop the action at all. You can switch between party members whenever you like, and a Limit Break gauge charges up for stronger attacks.
Critics liked that each character fights differently: Cloud up close with a sword, Barret from range. IGN's Tom Marks praised the combat system in particular. GamesRadar said every enemy has a weakness to find, which rewards planning over button-mashing. RPGamer welcomed the return of Materia for magic and the new upgradeable weapons, which let you decide how to build each character's kit.
Intergrade adds Yuffie, and critics disagreed on her too
Intergrade is the enhanced version, released on PlayStation 5 on June 10, 2021, then on Windows and, in 2026, on Nintendo Switch 2 and Xbox Series X and Series S. It adds a side story starring Yuffie, a new minigame and better graphics.
Yuffie split critics in a smaller version of the game's main argument. Siliconera found her young personality annoying, though it felt her relationship with Sonon improved the story. Destructoid found her likable, even realistic, and enjoyed her own style of play. Both praised the technical upgrade. GameSpot gave Intergrade a perfect score and pointed to the framerate, especially during Cloud's fights. PC Invasion praised the framerate as well and recommended the PC version over the others.
Critic aggregates sit at 87/100 across every platform listed, and the critic average computed from those critic scores is 8.7 out of 10.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q112663549 wikidata.org