Analysis · Fire Emblem Engage

Fire Emblem Engage puts the battles first and lets the story pay for it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who live for the next map

Fire Emblem Engage is for the tactics player who reads a grid map the way a chess player reads a board. The story, the social hub and the returning heroes all exist, but the game is organized around turn-based battles, and critics agreed that's where it earns its place.

You lead Alear, a dragon in human form who wakes from a thousand-year sleep, and an army that grows as the plot moves across Elyos. Battles alternate between your phase and the enemy's. Terrain matters: rivers stop ground units but not fliers, and fortresses grant evasion and restore health each turn. The series' weapon triangle returns (swords beat axes, axes beat lances, lances beat swords), and brawling attacks now beat bows, daggers and tomes.

Engage adds sharper tools on top of that. A hit with triangle advantage inflicts Break, which stops the target from counterattacking in that fight and its next one. Chain Attacks let nearby allies chip in, and Chain Guards let certain support classes cancel an attack on a neighbor. Then there are the 12 Emblem Rings, which hold phantom copies of heroes from earlier Fire Emblem games; a character wearing one can Engage, merging with that hero for a burst of power.

Where it delivers: some of the genre's best battles

The praise for the combat was close to unanimous. PJ O'Reilly of Nintendo Life wrote that the gameplay wasn't only the best in the series but among the finest in turn-based tactical RPGs as a whole. Even critics who disliked the game conceded the point: Hirun Cryer of GamesRadar+ called it a missed opportunity, yet still rated it one of the most absorbing turn-based games in years on gameplay alone.

The optional Paralogue missions drew specific credit. The late-game ones are each built around a single Emblem and stage a battle based on a chapter from that hero's original game, which gives longtime fans a reason to seek them out.

Reviewers also singled out the presentation: cutscenes, combat animations and a soundtrack with music fitted to each region. Classic mode keeps the series' permanent death for fallen units, while Casual mode only benches them for the rest of the map, and three difficulty levels sit on top of either choice.

Where it doesn't: a plot even its fans shrug at

Most critics called the story weak. They split on how much that mattered. Mike Mahardy of Polygon called the plot "nothing short of terrible" but liked that its short cutscenes get out of the way and move you from battle to battle. Chris Carter of Destructoid made a similar case, crediting the plot's energy and momentum.

The cast divided reviewers more sharply. Melanie Zawodniak of Nintendo World Report called it one of her favorite casts in the franchise, while others called the support conversations boring and the writing terrible.

The Emblems themselves are a mixed bag:

  • Brendan Graeber of IGN admired the respect the game shows for past Fire Emblem characters.
  • Others felt the Emblems took screen time away from the new human cast.
  • Ash Parrish of The Verge found the conversations between characters and Emblems short and shallow, and the Emblems rarely talk to each other.

Three Houses fans should set different expectations

Critics kept measuring Engage against Fire Emblem: Three Houses, and the comparison cuts both ways. Three Houses built its story on a painful war between former friends; Engage goes back to a plainer good-versus-evil fight against the Fell Dragon Sombron. Jordan Middler of Video Games Chronicle said Engage threw away many of the strengths that made its predecessor a hit, and Sisi Jiang of Kotaku wrote that it "took ten steps back" on story.

Renata Price of Waypoint captured the trade best: blander characters and a less ambitious setting than Three Houses, but missions and tactical depth that surpass it.

What you can safely ignore

Between battles, characters can relax and socialize in the Somniel. Reviewers found its minigames repetitive and dull, but they're optional and easy to skip. The same goes for the quasi-multiplayer modes, which Will Greenwald of PCMag called underwhelming and which most critics suggested passing over. Neither touches the part of the game worth playing.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet