Analysis · Foamstars

Foamstars has a clever foam-surfing core and too little built around it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Praised for its combat, faulted for running dry

Critics agreed on what works in Foamstars. IGN called its combat "engaging," and Eurogamer praised its movement. Eurogamer also gave the harshest verdict: after just three days, it said, the game "might have already exhausted its possibilities." Critics found the core of this 4v4 arena shooter good and the rest of the package thin.

The scores land in the middle. One aggregate puts it at 57/100 from 16 reviews of the PlayStation 4 and PlayStation 5 versions. Another gives 60/100 from 30 reviews, yet OpenCritic found only 17% of critics would recommend it. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 5.9 out of 10. An average near 60 with a recommend rate that low means critics found it competent but saw little reason to tell anyone to play it.

Foam is the weapon, the cover and the ride

The central idea is neat. Two teams of four shoot colored foam at each other. Foam does damage, and it also piles up into banks that players can surf on or hide behind. Standing in the other team's foam slows you down. Your ammo is also the terrain and a way to get around.

Knockouts work differently from most shooters. Drop to zero health and you're "foamed," stuck in a bubble until a teammate surfs into you and frees you. If an enemy surfs into you first, you're "chilled" and sent back to the starting point. That rescue window gives each fight a second chance to turn, and it probably explains much of the praise for the combat.

The game has eight characters, each with their own stats and abilities and an ultimate called a Superstar Skill. Digital Trends praised the characters along with the gameplay.

Where the praise runs out

The complaints fall into four groups:

  • Content. The PVP modes include Smash the Star, Happy Bath Survival and Rubber Duck Party, but Eurogamer felt the variety ran out within days.
  • Solo play. A separate PVE horde mode has you defend against waves of Bubble Beasties, alone or with others. IGN and Digital Trends both criticized the single-player side.
  • Monetization. Cosmetics, weapon skins, emotes and character packs come from a store or an optional battle pass. IGN criticized the microtransactions, and Digital Trends called them "ludicrous."
  • Polish. IGN faulted the optimization, and Digital Trends disliked the voice acting.

Progress also runs on its own currencies. Playing earns energy stones, which you exchange for bubble gems to upgrade characters. Two currencies plus a store is a lot to manage in a game critics already found short on things to do.

The Splatoon comparison and the generated art

As soon as Foamstars was revealed at the 2023 PlayStation Showcase, people compared it to Nintendo's Splatoon series. In both games, non-lethal ammo also works as movement and as a way to claim territory. In an editorial for Silconera, Leigh Price wrote that Nintendo doesn't own the idea. Price also pointed out that several weapons in the reveal trailer had direct Splatoon counterparts in both look and function. Producer Kosuke Okatani pushed back. He said the games differ a lot beyond that shared idea and proposed "party shooter" as a name for the genre.

At launch, players found that the cover art for the in-game music had been made with the image generator Midjourney. Square Enix confirmed it, said it wanted to "experiment," and put the generated assets at about 0.01% of the game's content or less. That is a tiny part of the game, but it brought another round of bad press at launch.

On May 14, 2024, Square Enix said Foamstars had missed its financial expectations, alongside Final Fantasy VII Rebirth and Final Fantasy XVI. It did not disclose sales figures.

For players, what matters is whether people are still in the queue. Foamstars is built around eight-player online matches, and a game that missed its publisher's expectations might not keep big crowds for long.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet