Analysis · Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance

Forged Alliance adds a fourth faction and keeps what critics liked

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics barely disagreed, so the real split is about the formula

For a strategy expansion, Forged Alliance produced very little argument. An aggregate of 10 critic reviews lands at 83/100. GameSpot's review, published on November 7, 2007, gave it 8.5 out of 10.0. Critics placed it at about the same level as the original Supreme Commander, which makes the critic average of 8.3 (calculated from those critic scores) easy to read: it was well liked and rarely disputed.

The narrowest point of agreement is also the most useful. The expansion keeps the original's gameplay almost unchanged, and critics rewarded it at the same level. So whether you'll like Forged Alliance depends less on the new content and more on whether Supreme Commander's style of play suits you. That style is demanding, and the expansion polishes it rather than reshaping it.

One giant robot, four kinds of battlefield

Every match begins with an Armored Command Unit, a huge two-legged mech that builds the army you use to beat your opponents. From there the game spreads across air, land, sea and information warfare. You run several fronts at once rather than winning one decisive fight.

That scale is the appeal, and it's also why some players won't enjoy it. The game expects you to manage an economy, a production line and several fronts at the same time. Critics rated both the original and this expansion highly, which suggests the design does what it sets out to do. It's still a design for players who enjoy juggling many tasks at once, not one built around tight squad tactics.

What the expansion actually adds

The headline addition is a new faction, the Seraphim, joining the United Earth Federation (UEF), the Cybran Nation and the Aeon Illuminate. The three original factions also get new units, some existing units were changed, and there are new maps.

  • Orbital weapons for the UEF. UEF players can build controllable satellites. Opponents can't damage the satellites directly, so they have to find and destroy the control centers that keep them running.
  • A revamped interface. The controls were reworked along with the parts players don't see directly.
  • Better pathfinding. Units find their way around the map more reliably.
  • Reworked aircraft flight. Air units fly differently than they did in the original.

The satellites deserve extra attention. You can't win by firing at them, so you have to scout and strike the right buildings instead. That fits a game where information is one of the four battlefields.

You don't need the original to start here

Forged Alliance is a stand-alone release, so you don't need a copy of Supreme Commander to play it. Because the core gameplay is the same and the interface and unit movement were improved, it's the obvious place for a newcomer to start. It runs on Microsoft Windows and the Xbox 360, with both single-player and multiplayer modes, and THQ published it.

The case for skipping it is just as clear. If the original didn't work for you, the expansion won't change your mind: the new faction, units and maps all build on the same foundation. The critical record is also small, with 10 reviews in the aggregate, so there's little detailed criticism to go on beyond a broad agreement that it matched the original.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet