Analysis · Forza Motorsport 4

Forza Motorsport 4 polished a great sim racer more than it reinvented one

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The argument was about progress, not quality

Almost no critic doubted that Forza Motorsport 4 was good. The critic aggregate in the record sits at 90/100 across 14 reviews. The real split was over how much it had changed since Forza Motorsport 3.

Jeff Gerstmann of Giant Bomb called it a "fantastic driving game" but felt it was only an incremental step, closer to a yearly sports update than a new entry. GameSpot's Justin Calvert agreed: refined, but "a little too familiar".

Others weighed the same changes differently. X-Play's Jason D'Aprile saw enough improvement over the previous game to crown it "the absolute king of the road". Edge granted that the series was getting familiar and still called it a more exciting drive than Gran Turismo 5. The changes were real but modest. How much they matter depends on what you're coming from.

What actually changed from Forza Motorsport 3

If you already own the previous game, these are the additions that count:

  • World Tour mode replaces Season Play. It tracks how well you drive and adjusts the difficulty, and AI drivers upgrade their cars to match you.
  • Prize cars are a choice now. Leveling up lets you pick one of several cars, each upgraded to the top of its class. In Forza 3 you got whatever the game handed you.
  • Autovista lets you walk around and inside 24 sports, classic and dream cars, looking at brake pads, engines and interiors, with audio notes on parts you point at.
  • More race types: drift, autocross and multiple-heat races sit alongside standard races.
  • Profile import carries some credits and gifted cars over from Forza 3. Car clubs let friends share cars from their garages.

None of that rebuilds the core driving, which is Gerstmann's point. But for anyone who skipped Forza 3, the familiarity complaint mostly goes away. You get the refined version of a series critics already loved.

Kinect is where critics agreed, and not kindly

Forza Motorsport 4 was the first game in the series to support the Kinect sensor. You can steer by holding your arms out around an invisible wheel while the game handles the gas and brake for you. You can also use voice commands to start races and move through menus, or use head tracking to look toward a corner's apex while driving with a controller or steering wheel.

Reviewers weren't won over. D'Aprile called the Kinect support "a gimmick". Game Informer's Matthew Kato said Kinect racing isn't satisfying because your arms get tired and the game drives the pedals for you.

Plan on a controller or a steering wheel. Treat Kinect as an extra for Autovista and menus, not as a way to race.

Who the praise points to

Newcomers and mixed-skill households. 1UP.com's Jose Otero called it "the most accessible racer around". He pointed to the game suggesting upgrades when a car isn't tuned for an event, and to the Rewind feature for replaying a bad section. Seasoned drivers can switch the assists off.

Car obsessives. IGN's Luke Reilly praised the detail in Autovista, down to the small parts, and enjoyed Jeremy Clarkson's "refreshingly candid" commentary. Official Xbox Magazine's Ryan McCaffrey praised the 60 fps frame rate, the views and the sound design, enough that he drove from the cockpit view the whole time.

The complaints were small but specific. Reilly wanted evening races. McCaffrey found the soundtrack out of place and muted it. D'Aprile wanted more Top Gear content.

The more telling note came from Eurogamer's Martin Robinson. He found it "easy to fall in love with", but said it often didn't capture the emotion its cars can inspire, compared with the passion he saw in Gran Turismo 5. If you want romance as much as precision, that's the gap to expect. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences still named it Racing Game of the Year.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet