Forza Motorsport 5 drives beautifully on a much shorter car list
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A launch showpiece that arrived smaller than the last game
Forza Motorsport 5 is the fifth Forza Motorsport and the sixth game in the wider Forza series. Turn 10 Studios built it as a launch title for Xbox One, and it came out on November 22, 2013. That timing explains most of what critics liked and most of what they didn't. It was the new console's showpiece racer, and it was smaller than Forza Motorsport 4, the game before it.
The reviews divide along that line. It scored 79 out of 100 on Metacritic and 79.49% on GameRankings, and the critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 8.3 out of 10. Reviewers mostly agreed on how it drives. They disagreed on whether there was enough of it.
What changed: rivals that race like people
The biggest new idea was the computer-controlled field. In Polygon, Arthur Gies praised its "aggressive, convincing AI" and said it made each offline race feel like a race against real people online. He called the game the Xbox One's "first must-own game." That's high praise for a feature that's easy to overlook, because tougher, more human opponents change every single race.
Other critics responded to the game's tone. GameSpot's Shaun McInnis said its love for motorsport is close to impossible to resist. IGN's Luke Reilly called it "an essential destination" for people obsessed with cars.
The presentation grew too. Jeremy Clarkson came back from Forza Motorsport 4 and was joined by his Top Gear co-presenters James May and Richard Hammond. Their narration plays when you choose a new event, championship or league. The career mode was also reworked, and that change got a much colder reception.
What it kept: a simulation you can ease into
Underneath, this is still a Forza Motorsport. You race real licensed cars on real and fictional courses around the world. Arcade mode covers quick races, and career mode is built for long-term play. Career runs from everyday commuter cars up to racing series such as Super GT and Deutsche Tourenwagen Masters.
Newer players get the series' usual assists:
- an ideal racing line drawn on the track
- anti-lock brakes
- traction control
Championships are grouped by manufacturer region, car age, power, drivetrain and racing discipline. Each one is a set of races with better rewards, while single exhibition races take less time. Split-screen and Xbox Live multiplayer are both included. EGM's Ray Carsillo said the game keeps the series' tradition of great control and very realistic graphics.
What it cut, and why critics couldn't let it go
The common complaint was simple: there was less game. Edge counted roughly 300 fewer cars, more than 20 fewer locations and many fewer tracks than Forza Motorsport 4. It said the game had lost the variety that made the series great.
Edge called it "a launch game with all the spectacle and disappointment" readers had come to expect from launch games.
Game Informer's Matthew Kato called the revised career mode "a mistake." He argued the game took a big step forward and was then held back by what it removed. Carsillo, despite liking the handling, still called it "a surprising step backward" for the series.
Players bought it anyway. On February 18, 2014, Microsoft announced it was the fastest-selling racing game in Xbox history, with more than a third of Xbox One owners buying it. At the 17th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards it won Racing Game of the Year and was nominated for Outstanding Achievement in Gameplay Engineering. The cuts are real, but they didn't stop it from being the racer people chose on the new console.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Forza Motorsport 5 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q13361633 wikidata.org