Analysis · Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare 2

Garden Warfare 2 puts serious shooter bones under a silly cartoon war

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A silly war with a real shooter underneath

The whole game rests on one contrast. It looks like a children's cartoon about sunflowers and shambling zombies, but critics said it plays like the Battlefield series: team third-person shooting built on classes and objectives. Reviewers liked that pairing. They praised how goofy it is next to other shooters and pointed out that the childish look covers mechanics with real depth.

That contrast is the test for everything else in the sequel. A new feature works when it adds to the silliness or to the shooting, and ideally to both. Most of what PopCap added does.

Ten new classes give the zombies equal billing

The roster grows by 10 classes. Six are available from the start, two have to be earned through a series of tough trials, and two only appear in the endless mode. The new plants are Citron, Rose, Kernel Corn and Torchwood. The new zombies are Imp, Super Brainz, Captain Deadbeard and Hover Goat-3000. Returning characters also get new abilities, and the full game includes forty different characters across twelve maps.

The bigger change is balance. This sequel adds Graveyard Ops, a zombie version of the cooperative Garden Ops mode. It also adds Herbal Assault, which turns the old Gardens and Graveyards mode around so the zombies defend bases while the plants try to capture them, with up to 24 players. Critics welcomed the extra zombie playtime and said the two teams finally felt equal.

Polygon's Gies still found that playing as the zombies "just isn't quite as fun" as playing the plants.

So the two sides get equal content, though not quite equal charm. That fits the core idea: the plant cast simply lands the joke more often.

Solo play finally means something

In the original Garden Warfare, the only way to play alone was Garden Ops in private mode. In the sequel, you can play every mode solo except the ones exclusive to the mystery portal, such as Capture the Taco and Soil Survivors. There are also new single-player campaigns, which several critics enjoyed and credited with introducing the six new classes well.

Giant Bomb's Shoemaker added a fair caveat: the campaign missions rarely get elaborate and are mostly reworked versions of the existing multiplayer mechanics. That's a real limit, but it suits the game's core idea. The solo content teaches you the shooter you'll play online. It doesn't pretend to be a separate story game.

Between matches you're in Backyard Battleground, a hub you can roam freely. It has:

  • portals into missions, plus moon-based missions and a shooting gallery
  • waves of enemy heroes, along with crates that drop coins or an AI ally
  • plant pots where you can build plant turrets or zombie bots
  • Flag of Power matches, a King of the Hill-style mode against AI that you can start whenever you like
  • collectibles to find, and bobbleheads of the characters you've unlocked

Each side's base also has a customization room, a quest board, sticker shops and a mailbox. Split-screen and private servers round it out, and free extra content kept arriving regularly after launch.

Coins, stickers and a light hand on spending

Cosmetics come from sticker shops, paid for with in-game coins, and you can buy those coins with real money. Some critics didn't like the microtransactions but judged that they did no real harm. The game doesn't show ads pushing you to spend, and Electronic Gaming Monthly's Campbell said he never felt compelled to buy currency.

That restraint matters for a game this colorful, which will draw younger players. You earn coins by playing, so the shop stays an extra rather than a requirement.

Where the critics landed

Metacritic rated the reviews "generally favorable". The aggregate scores sit around 80/100, including an 81/100 across 71 reviews, and the critic average computed from those aggregates is 8.0. Scores barely differ across the PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Windows versions. In the UK, the retail version debuted at number 2 on the sales chart in its launch week, behind Far Cry Primal.

Critics consistently described a sequel that kept what the first game did well and fixed its two biggest gaps, solo play and zombie content, without losing the joke.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet