Analysis · Gears of War 2

Gears of War 2 split critics on its online play, never on Horde or co-op

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The fight was over multiplayer, not the campaign

Critics agreed on almost everything about Gears of War 2 except its competitive multiplayer. Reviewers noted that versus play didn't feel like the first game's, especially in its pace and how much fun it was. IGN reported bugs and lag online. Yet X-Play called the multiplayer "brilliant," and Game Informer described it as "an outstanding contrast" to team deathmatch and capture-the-flag modes.

That split matters more than the scores. The critic aggregate GameRaven draws on lands at 92/100 across nine reviews, which gives a critic average of 9.2, and Metacritic sits at 93/100. Numbers that high hide where the reservations live. Here they live almost entirely in one mode.

So the question for a buyer is simple. Are you here for the story and co-op, or for ranked-style versus matches? The first group has little to worry about. The second should read the complaints closely.

What the game asks of you in a firefight

This is a third-person shooter built around cover. You play as Marcus or Dominic in the campaign and carry a pistol, one type of grenade and two other weapons, swapping them for guns found on the map or dropped by fallen enemies and allies.

The sequel rebalances the old arsenal and adds five new weapons:

  • a flamethrower
  • a chain gun and a mortar cannon, both heavy weapons that slow you to a walk
  • the Gorgon Pistol, a machine pistol that fires four-shot bursts
  • the Ink Grenade, which does no blast damage but poisons an area to flush enemies out of cover

The Lancer rifle's chainsaw bayonet still kills in one melee hit, and two Lancer users can now lock into a chainsaw duel decided by rapid button presses. Downed players can crawl for help, get revived, be executed, or be grabbed and used as a meatshield. X-Play singled out the "polished cover system," and that combat loop is the part nobody faulted.

Horde mode is where critics found the long tail

If one feature explains the game's staying power in reviews, it's Horde mode. IGN and Eurogamer both praised it. Eurogamer called it "a weighty slab of fun" that can turn nearly any map into a time-sink, and compared its leaderboards to the leveling hook of Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare.

That matters for the multiplayer worry above. Horde is cooperative, so the lag and balance complaints about versus play don't weigh on it the same way. Game Informer went further on co-op in general, calling the cooperative campaign amazing and the solo campaign "satisfying."

The safest reason to pick this up is to play it with someone else, against the computer.

A bigger story with a soft middle and a weak finish

Critics credited Gears of War 2 with a deeper plot than the first game, with comic book writer Joshua Ortega brought in to help write it. Reviewers also called it highly polished.

The praise has limits. Official Xbox Magazine said much of the plot in the middle acts "falls flat." IGN liked the first four acts but called the last boss "a complete joke" and said the ending felt abrupt. IGN also warned that the voice acting might put some players off.

None of that sank the game for IGN, which still named it one of the best games on the Xbox 360. It does mean the story is a reason to keep going, not the reason to start. Note too that it's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18, though an optional filter turns blood into sparks and cuts the harsh language.

Who gets the most from it

The record points to a clear reader. Someone who wants a cover shooter to play through with a friend, then keep returning to Horde, gets the best of what critics loved. Someone who mainly wants tight competitive matches gets the part reviewers argued about, on a platform where online play was the weakest link IGN found.

Solo players sit in between. The campaign is long on spectacle and well built, but expect a slower middle and an ending that doesn't match the first four acts.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet